Like the thread title says, whats so bad about his games? It can't be sales because his games sell a bit more than a million especially when you combine the sales of multiplatform games. I can't seem to figure out why people bash it. Anyone here know?

It is not Mario nuff said.

Because his games used to be as good as Mario games (even better in some peoples' eyes) and now they almost universally suck (I'll give Sonic Rush a pass but not SR Adventure).

It's really as simple as that.

Because most of the new Sonic games pale in comparison to what we enjoyed with the Genesis.

They are not what they used to be...

Sonic sucks compared to mario.

Explain please.

Mario suck compared to Sonic. See, I can do that too. Thats just an opinion.

Very few of them are good compared to others. The originals are really good and sonic rush is fantastic. But so many are not as good and look bad by comparrison, such as the new Sonic the hedgehog on PS3 and Xbox 360. That said I love sonic games

 Sonic games on Genesis and DC =  GREAT!

Sonic now =  Sucky games or avarage but never so good like the first games.

I am a huge sonic fan and I can tell you that the last sonic games made me cry.

I thought this thread was about =  Why you don't like Sonic X_X.