By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - What if we all started shooting down those Russian bombers?

Mr Khan said:
Joelcool7 said:
Sharu said:
Joelcool7 said:

I was in another thread today and mentioned how Russian bombers entered Canadian airspace, and how we scramble CF-18's to escort them out into international air space. But after doing so I thought well so far this year I have heard about Russian bombers violating Japanese air space, British Air space, Taiwanes air space.

Do you have any reliable link to this news? 'cause really Russian military aircrafts was flying in the international area, totally legal. When they were moving close to National borders of some countries - then country's planes come closer to it. I think its quite a good training for both of the armies. :)

And by the way - don't be afraid of Russians - we are very friendly. ;) And if you'll check some history you'll see that most of the time 'Russian Ivan' just fights back from our nice western friends... :)

I'm not afraid of Russian's nor do I have any anger or hatred towards the people of Russia. Its the Government of Russia which I fear and do not trust. A Government where journalists who opposed Putin mysteriously died. Ex-KGB agents either work for the current government or die from radiation poisoning in Britain. A country where their is democracy but anyone who opposes specific parties mysteriously die or pull out. I am afraid when Putin and such say that the cold war is restarting or how peace keepers invade Goergia and annex a ton of its land.

Thats all I could go into history of how the Soviets treated mennonites etc...etc... but that has nothing to do with modern Russia. Lets just say I don't like your countries Government!

Whoa there. Georgia started that one, invading semi-autonomous territories with the intent of revoking their autonomy, in an effort that they had to have known would lead to them getting their asses kicked by Russia, but it was their choice to start it

That's not what the reports showed last check.

Last I saw they invaded because those regions started firing artilliery into their land.

I find it less the coincidental that a lot of minor russian officals are also now ossetian ministers.



Around the Network
Kasz216 said:
Mr Khan said:
Joelcool7 said:
Sharu said:
Joelcool7 said:

I was in another thread today and mentioned how Russian bombers entered Canadian airspace, and how we scramble CF-18's to escort them out into international air space. But after doing so I thought well so far this year I have heard about Russian bombers violating Japanese air space, British Air space, Taiwanes air space.

Do you have any reliable link to this news? 'cause really Russian military aircrafts was flying in the international area, totally legal. When they were moving close to National borders of some countries - then country's planes come closer to it. I think its quite a good training for both of the armies. :)

And by the way - don't be afraid of Russians - we are very friendly. ;) And if you'll check some history you'll see that most of the time 'Russian Ivan' just fights back from our nice western friends... :)

I'm not afraid of Russian's nor do I have any anger or hatred towards the people of Russia. Its the Government of Russia which I fear and do not trust. A Government where journalists who opposed Putin mysteriously died. Ex-KGB agents either work for the current government or die from radiation poisoning in Britain. A country where their is democracy but anyone who opposes specific parties mysteriously die or pull out. I am afraid when Putin and such say that the cold war is restarting or how peace keepers invade Goergia and annex a ton of its land.

Thats all I could go into history of how the Soviets treated mennonites etc...etc... but that has nothing to do with modern Russia. Lets just say I don't like your countries Government!

Whoa there. Georgia started that one, invading semi-autonomous territories with the intent of revoking their autonomy, in an effort that they had to have known would lead to them getting their asses kicked by Russia, but it was their choice to start it

That's not what the reports showed last check.

Last I saw they invaded because those regions started firing artilliery into their land.

I find it less the coincidental that a lot of minor russian officals are also now ossetian ministers.

Well, yeah, that was what prompted Georgia to invade at the end of it all (or so they claim), but that was merely the tail end of violence dating back to June 2008, the root cause of which is murky in the whole "who shot first?" deal, and the casue of that violence goes back still further to Georgian efforts to undermine the autonomous government by establishing a counter-government in Tbilisi



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Mr Khan said:
Kasz216 said:
Mr Khan said:
Joelcool7 said:
Sharu said:
Joelcool7 said:

I was in another thread today and mentioned how Russian bombers entered Canadian airspace, and how we scramble CF-18's to escort them out into international air space. But after doing so I thought well so far this year I have heard about Russian bombers violating Japanese air space, British Air space, Taiwanes air space.

Do you have any reliable link to this news? 'cause really Russian military aircrafts was flying in the international area, totally legal. When they were moving close to National borders of some countries - then country's planes come closer to it. I think its quite a good training for both of the armies. :)

And by the way - don't be afraid of Russians - we are very friendly. ;) And if you'll check some history you'll see that most of the time 'Russian Ivan' just fights back from our nice western friends... :)

I'm not afraid of Russian's nor do I have any anger or hatred towards the people of Russia. Its the Government of Russia which I fear and do not trust. A Government where journalists who opposed Putin mysteriously died. Ex-KGB agents either work for the current government or die from radiation poisoning in Britain. A country where their is democracy but anyone who opposes specific parties mysteriously die or pull out. I am afraid when Putin and such say that the cold war is restarting or how peace keepers invade Goergia and annex a ton of its land.

Thats all I could go into history of how the Soviets treated mennonites etc...etc... but that has nothing to do with modern Russia. Lets just say I don't like your countries Government!

Whoa there. Georgia started that one, invading semi-autonomous territories with the intent of revoking their autonomy, in an effort that they had to have known would lead to them getting their asses kicked by Russia, but it was their choice to start it

That's not what the reports showed last check.

Last I saw they invaded because those regions started firing artilliery into their land.

I find it less the coincidental that a lot of minor russian officals are also now ossetian ministers.

Well, yeah, that was what prompted Georgia to invade at the end of it all (or so they claim), but that was merely the tail end of violence dating back to June 2008, the root cause of which is murky in the whole "who shot first?" deal, and the casue of that violence goes back still further to Georgian efforts to undermine the autonomous government by establishing a counter-government in Tbilisi

As far as I know those autonomous territories were legally Goergian territory. Goergia had a civil war going on where the Ossetian's were fighting to create their own country. They however were not recognized by the rest of the world as an independant country. Infact Nato and the UN mostly considered that soil to be Goergian. Goergia attacked the rebels to unify the country and win the civil war, however Russia moved in tons of troops and faught Goergia out of its territory then single handadly recognized the Ossetian territory as independant.

Its like Chechnya for example. Their are thousands of rebels fighting for an independant state. At times these rebels have formed their own Governments. These rebels right daily, now how would Russia like it if Nato invaded and declaired Chechnya an independant country?

A civil war is a civil war. Russia just decided to go in and divide Goergia up. Goergia could have won the war a nd unified the country which infact is what they were doing before Russia interfered. Only the UN has the right to draw up borders and consider new countries independant.

Russia can't just draw borders where ever they feel like, theirs do process to be followed.



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer

 

Joelcool7 said:
Mr Khan said:
Kasz216 said:
Mr Khan said:
Joelcool7 said:
Sharu said:
Joelcool7 said:

I was in another thread today and mentioned how Russian bombers entered Canadian airspace, and how we scramble CF-18's to escort them out into international air space. But after doing so I thought well so far this year I have heard about Russian bombers violating Japanese air space, British Air space, Taiwanes air space.

Do you have any reliable link to this news? 'cause really Russian military aircrafts was flying in the international area, totally legal. When they were moving close to National borders of some countries - then country's planes come closer to it. I think its quite a good training for both of the armies. :)

And by the way - don't be afraid of Russians - we are very friendly. ;) And if you'll check some history you'll see that most of the time 'Russian Ivan' just fights back from our nice western friends... :)

I'm not afraid of Russian's nor do I have any anger or hatred towards the people of Russia. Its the Government of Russia which I fear and do not trust. A Government where journalists who opposed Putin mysteriously died. Ex-KGB agents either work for the current government or die from radiation poisoning in Britain. A country where their is democracy but anyone who opposes specific parties mysteriously die or pull out. I am afraid when Putin and such say that the cold war is restarting or how peace keepers invade Goergia and annex a ton of its land.

Thats all I could go into history of how the Soviets treated mennonites etc...etc... but that has nothing to do with modern Russia. Lets just say I don't like your countries Government!

Whoa there. Georgia started that one, invading semi-autonomous territories with the intent of revoking their autonomy, in an effort that they had to have known would lead to them getting their asses kicked by Russia, but it was their choice to start it

That's not what the reports showed last check.

Last I saw they invaded because those regions started firing artilliery into their land.

I find it less the coincidental that a lot of minor russian officals are also now ossetian ministers.

Well, yeah, that was what prompted Georgia to invade at the end of it all (or so they claim), but that was merely the tail end of violence dating back to June 2008, the root cause of which is murky in the whole "who shot first?" deal, and the casue of that violence goes back still further to Georgian efforts to undermine the autonomous government by establishing a counter-government in Tbilisi

A civil war is a civil war. Russia just decided to go in and divide Goergia up. Goergia could have won the war a nd unified the country which infact is what they were doing before Russia interfered. Only the UN has the right to draw up borders and consider new countries independant.

Russia can't just draw borders where ever they feel like, theirs do process to be followed.

If you want to speak seriously about this - it can be done if you are interested...

And regarding drawing borders and invading countries without UN approval - look into Yugoslavia and Iraq.



Sharu said:
Joelcool7 said:
Mr Khan said:
Kasz216 said:
Mr Khan said:
Joelcool7 said:
Sharu said:
Joelcool7 said:

I was in another thread today and mentioned how Russian bombers entered Canadian airspace, and how we scramble CF-18's to escort them out into international air space. But after doing so I thought well so far this year I have heard about Russian bombers violating Japanese air space, British Air space, Taiwanes air space.

Do you have any reliable link to this news? 'cause really Russian military aircrafts was flying in the international area, totally legal. When they were moving close to National borders of some countries - then country's planes come closer to it. I think its quite a good training for both of the armies. :)

And by the way - don't be afraid of Russians - we are very friendly. ;) And if you'll check some history you'll see that most of the time 'Russian Ivan' just fights back from our nice western friends... :)

I'm not afraid of Russian's nor do I have any anger or hatred towards the people of Russia. Its the Government of Russia which I fear and do not trust. A Government where journalists who opposed Putin mysteriously died. Ex-KGB agents either work for the current government or die from radiation poisoning in Britain. A country where their is democracy but anyone who opposes specific parties mysteriously die or pull out. I am afraid when Putin and such say that the cold war is restarting or how peace keepers invade Goergia and annex a ton of its land.

Thats all I could go into history of how the Soviets treated mennonites etc...etc... but that has nothing to do with modern Russia. Lets just say I don't like your countries Government!

Whoa there. Georgia started that one, invading semi-autonomous territories with the intent of revoking their autonomy, in an effort that they had to have known would lead to them getting their asses kicked by Russia, but it was their choice to start it

That's not what the reports showed last check.

Last I saw they invaded because those regions started firing artilliery into their land.

I find it less the coincidental that a lot of minor russian officals are also now ossetian ministers.

Well, yeah, that was what prompted Georgia to invade at the end of it all (or so they claim), but that was merely the tail end of violence dating back to June 2008, the root cause of which is murky in the whole "who shot first?" deal, and the casue of that violence goes back still further to Georgian efforts to undermine the autonomous government by establishing a counter-government in Tbilisi

A civil war is a civil war. Russia just decided to go in and divide Goergia up. Goergia could have won the war a nd unified the country which infact is what they were doing before Russia interfered. Only the UN has the right to draw up borders and consider new countries independant.

Russia can't just draw borders where ever they feel like, theirs do process to be followed.

If you want to speak seriously about this - it can be done if you are interested...

And regarding drawing borders and invading countries without UN approval - look into Yugoslavia and Iraq.


I of course disagree with the US invasion of Iraq. However the US is pulling out and Iraq remains a soveirgn state. The US is set to fully withdraw and the country itself remains united. Its not like the US came into Iraq and decided well this part of the country should be seperated from the rest, lets draw up a new border put some American Government officials into the Iraq Government. How about making Kurdistan its own country?

Russia annexed a huge hunk of the country and put their own Government leaders into powerful positions and essentially now occupy a huge part of a country which the UN deems a soveirgn state. Also the country was looking to join Nato and Nato was highly considering them. It was provacative and unlawful occupation.

 

Yes I love speaking seriously about politics.



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer

 

Around the Network
Joelcool7 said:
Sharu said:

If you want to speak seriously about this - it can be done if you are interested...

And regarding drawing borders and invading countries without UN approval - look into Yugoslavia and Iraq.


I of course disagree with the US invasion of Iraq. However the US is pulling out and Iraq remains a soveirgn state. The US is set to fully withdraw and the country itself remains united. Its not like the US came into Iraq and decided well this part of the country should be seperated from the rest, lets draw up a new border put some American Government officials into the Iraq Government. How about making Kurdistan its own country?

Russia annexed a huge hunk of the country and put their own Government leaders into powerful positions and essentially now occupy a huge part of a country which the UN deems a soveirgn state. Also the country was looking to join Nato and Nato was highly considering them. It was provacative and unlawful occupation.

 

Yes I love speaking seriously about politics.

It's very different. Chechnya's autonomy was never recognized (except de facto from 1996 to 1999), whereas Georgia agreed to treat Abkhazia and South Ossetia as autonomous territories after wars in 1992 and 1994. Georgia knew the consequences of trying to revoke their autonomy by force, and went in anyway, and Georgia was trying to use its status as a NATO candidate and NATO's general frostiness with Russia at the time as a potential shield (in a sort of "hey Russia you can't stop us from doing this because i'll get my big bro America to kick your ass!"), which clearly wasn't the case

At the start of the war, the South Ossetian war was entirely Georgia's fault, and most international observers agree to this (except people with a vested anti-Russian interest, like the Baltic states and Poland). Russia was condemned for a disproportionate response, but they did abandon their control of *uncontested* Georgia, and didn't take out Saakashvili even if they totally could have



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Mr Khan said:
Joelcool7 said:
Sharu said:
 

If you want to speak seriously about this - it can be done if you are interested...

And regarding drawing borders and invading countries without UN approval - look into Yugoslavia and Iraq.


I of course disagree with the US invasion of Iraq. However the US is pulling out and Iraq remains a soveirgn state. The US is set to fully withdraw and the country itself remains united. Its not like the US came into Iraq and decided well this part of the country should be seperated from the rest, lets draw up a new border put some American Government officials into the Iraq Government. How about making Kurdistan its own country?

Russia annexed a huge hunk of the country and put their own Government leaders into powerful positions and essentially now occupy a huge part of a country which the UN deems a soveirgn state. Also the country was looking to join Nato and Nato was highly considering them. It was provacative and unlawful occupation.

 

Yes I love speaking seriously about politics.

It's very different. Chechnya's autonomy was never recognized (except de facto from 1996 to 1999), whereas Georgia agreed to treat Abkhazia and South Ossetia as autonomous territories after wars in 1992 and 1994. Georgia knew the consequences of trying to revoke their autonomy by force, and went in anyway, and Georgia was trying to use its status as a NATO candidate and NATO's general frostiness with Russia at the time as a potential shield (in a sort of "hey Russia you can't stop us from doing this because i'll get my big bro America to kick your ass!"), which clearly wasn't the case

At the start of the war, the South Ossetian war was entirely Georgia's fault, and most international observers agree to this (except people with a vested anti-Russian interest, like the Baltic states and Poland). Russia was condemned for a disproportionate response, but they did abandon their control of *uncontested* Georgia, and didn't take out Saakashvili even if they totally could have

Really?  All the observers i've seen have blamed Russia for convincing Ossetia to attack.  That is the observers that were there when the whole thing started.

Afterall, that's what most of the world's countries believe as well.

I can't see there being such a divid between the observers and the countries.



afaik, all russias bomber flights take place in international airspace.  even if they are close to our own, shooting down one of them would make us the bad guy...regardless of russia being a corrupt mafia state.



"I like my steaks how i like my women.  Bloody and all over my face"

"Its like sex, but with a winner!"

MrBubbles Review Threads: Bill Gates, Jak II, Kingdom Hearts II, The Strangers, Sly 2, Crackdown, Zohan, Quarantine, Klungo Sssavesss Teh World, MS@E3'08, WATCHMEN(movie), Shadow of the Colossus, The Saboteur

Joelcool7 said:
ultima said:

You really need to calm down. First of all, these are human pilots that you're suggesting we shoot down.

Secondly, consider what would happen if one of Russian bombers were to be shot down. As you can imagine Russia would not be happy. If they decided to invade us there's nothing we'd be able to do to stop them. Sure, bring out NATO, but they'll find a way not to get involved. Maybe they'll say we drew the first punch with shooting the planes... Most of NATO is Europe, and guess who's keeping Europe warm in the cold of the winter? Guess what would happen if Russia were to suddenly stop supplying oil and gas to them, especially now? You get the picture. US may back us up, but that would only make it worse. An armed conflict between Russia and US equals WW3 equals nuclear apocalypse.

So take it easy man. Maybe give that Call of Duty a rest.

Man you tell me to lay off the Call Of Duty but seriously Russia would never be foolish enough to invade Canada. You mention Nato would not stand behind us, well the U.K certainly would and so would France and the US. You mention the gas but Canada is the most resource laden country on earth. More fresh water then anywhere else on earth, more lumber , one of the largest gas producing countries which Europe could simply start importing from Canada. Canada is also a commonwealth country and one of the U.K most important allies.

Russia would be extremely stupid to start a huge war over the loss of one or two bombers. Example South Korea looses a ship full of Naval troops, an island is pummeled to hell yet they do not fire on North Korea. Why don't they, because they know it is not in their best interest.

As for in this imaginary scenerio where Russia has the balls to invade Canada. The US may support us? The US would have to support us for the very reasons you say that Europe would not. A huge amount of the US electricity comes from Canada, future water supplies...Canada, minerals and metals, Canada. The US relies heavily on Canada for many of their natural resources. Also the US would never allow Russia to occupy a nation on its border.

In the case of Russia invading Canada it would ignite WWIII, Nato and the United States would be at war with Russia. The whole world would collapse on itself and if Nukes began flying it would be the end. Canada is extremely important to Europe and the US even more so. Nobody would dare invade us, Russia heck even the US wouldn't dare invade Canada. On a global scale Canada has as many allies as the US if not more liked globally.

But as I said , Russia would not invade Canada if we shot down a plane. They would send some stern words our way and maybe worst case scenerio close the Canadian Embassy and expell the Canadian Ambassador for a year or two. You need to stop watching so many movies, Russia is not as stupid as you think they are.

Also if you read my initial post shooting down the bombers was just one of three suggestions I made. I used it in the title to get the general idea across that this thread is about standing up to Russia. I also suggested seizing the air craft and arresting the pilots. Much more civil and would probubly send the same message!

1. What makes you think UK and France would back us up? Sure they'll urge Russia to calm down, but there's no way they'd get their hands dirty against someone so powerful. This isn't Iraq we're talking about. This is the country with the largest arsenal of nuclear weapons and the means by which to single handedly destroy every living thing on this planet. Yes, that includes humans.

2. I'd appreciate if you stopped making "facts" up. Brazil has the most freshwater in the world, followed by Russia. Canada is third. As for lumber: Russia has almost thrice the forest area of Canada. Brazil, as well, has 50% more forest area than Canada.

3. Europe could not "simply start importing gas from Canada." For them to be able to do that a pipeline must exist connecting us to them. In case you're not aware, a vast ocean divides us; building and maintaining a pipeline across an ocean would be extremely expensive. Plus it would take a few decades before it would be ready for use. And even then Canadian gas would be much much more expensive for the Europeans compared to Russian gas.

4. I never said Russia is stupid. Granted my scenario of Russia invading us was exagerated, but do you still want get on the black list of the second most powerful military nation in the world (arguably first if you consider nukes)? Plus, this is exactly the kind of behaviour we're internationally not known for. That is in fact one of the reasons pretty much every nation in the world respects us.



           

I tell you what I would do.

I would go get all my friends guns and mine.  Load them, Clean them and test them. GO buy some more guns, The same MM so I can have same ammo and stock up big time. Stock up on some food and if nothing happens well atleast I was ready.

SHoot the f out of anything that move! J/k but not if sh-t was hidding the fan.