The ending was cool but it killed any chance of me getting the next RDR.
If John is not in it then I dont care. Here is a tip for R*, if you are making a trilogy dont kill your main character, not so early in the series, that just makes people lose connection. I know you guys were going for the "Coen Brothers Hollywood cowboy movie ending," but this is not a movie, it's a game, and gamers get very attached to their main character.

Anyway, good luck with RDR2, you lost me on that one, unless it's a prequel and we get to play as John when he was still buds with Bill and Dutch.
This reminds of when Kojima used Raiden for Metal Gear Solid 2 instead of Snake, it was just wrong and not cool, and just a complete disconnect.

What do you guys think of the ending?

i thought the ending was jacked up but it made sense mainly because of all he had done. I mean he killed alot of people when he was in that gang still i hate he got killed the way he did. Though maybe R* will make downloadable content showing his son killing that cop that lied to john. who knows lol

<table style="width: 90%;" border="0"><tr><td><strong>Mad55 said:</strong><br /><p>i thought the ending was jacked up but it made sense mainly because of all he had done. I mean he killed alot of people when he was in that gang still i hate he got killed the way he did. Though maybe R* will make downloadable content showing his son killing that cop that lied to john. who knows lol</p></td></tr></table><br /><br />

umm? you quoted me or someting

really oh hell gotta fininsh the rest of the stranger quests then