Favourite Gears of War Game?

[curl-6]

Shiken said:
The only thing this poll tells me is that Gears games are quality games outside of 4 and judgement...and that does not mean they are bad so much as not on par with the rest. Between 1,2, 3, and 5 the fan base seems pretty divided, which is good as far as a long running franchise goes.

I'd say Judgement is definitely a "quality game". It may lack the huge setpieces of 1-3 but it still has the same awesome combat and I for one really liked the arcadey star rating system that encouraged skillful play and broke the game up into bite-sized "just one more" chunks that helped keep the pace quick and addictive.