Barkley said:
North America hasn't been close to being a Nintendo plurality in recent years, they're doing it so far this year but that could change and I wouldn't look at just a few months when determing who's territory is who's. (VGC Figures used below.) The past three years USA has been a Sony Plurality. 2016 - Nintendo Systems: 2.85m , Microsoft Systems: 4.98m , Sony Systems: 5.32m 2013 was the last time Nintendo were on top in USA, back when Wii/DS sales still had an impact. Japan is a Nintendo Majority though, with the exception of 2016 where Sony was the majority. |
North America has historically been a Nintendo plurality, and in the present they are a Nintendo plurality. Those three years you listed are actually some of the worst years Nintendo has ever had in the United States, with 2016 being the absolute worst year since they started in 1985. Nintendo doesn't have a plurality only when they release extremely unappealing hardware like the 3DS and Wii U.
I wouldn't be surprised if the only years Sony has ever won in the US were 2016, 2015, 2014, 2005, and 2001. They certainly lost from 2006 to 2013 thanks to the Wii and DS, and they also lost from 1995 to 2000 thanks to the Game Boy. Even the sixth generation likely went to Nintendo for the most part because of the Game Boy Advance, which did incredibly well in North America.