It'll be an interesting contest for sales and critical reception. First party titles seem to do well on WiiU so it won't be a low bar for sales by any means, and Zelda is a series that consistently scores in the low to mid 90's for meta so that too is not a low bar for Horizon to surpass. I'd love to see Horizon do well enough to fulfill your prediction as it would be a really encouraging sign for the developer and keep them on this path which I find much more interesting than Killzone.
...