I think both are awful games, especially when you compare the reboot to the PS1 TR2/3, those games were in a leauge of their own. The freedom of exploration was thrown out of the window with the reboot just to unchartify it. Maybe that changed with the new exclusive TR? Didn't care enough to check. But good for the rest gamers, judging by the reviews and sales, they seem happy with the new direction that the reboot took.
I always felt the same when it comes to Resident Evil. 4 was good but everything after that didn't really feel like Resident Evil to me anymore.
And I will always think that TR1 is the best of the old games. By far. It had a very huge impact on me when I was young which the successors couldn't replicate.