Andrew Garfield definitely should come back. His acting felt more believable as Peter Parker & Spiderman. I felt like Andrew didn't get a good enough chance to show his stuff because the actual story wasn't that amazing. Like having the perfect actor yet the script is horrible type of scenario.
Toby Maguire just wasn't believable, just some actor that luckily got the part. Kirsten Dunst was also an ugly Mary Jane.