Critically panned games that you love?

[Vikki]

Michael-5 said:

Too Human. It's a very flawed game, one which overall feels unfinished since it's missing whole cinematics, reuses the same dialogue repeatedly, and even re-uses unique characters who fight with you (i.e. there are random clones of people).

Project Sylpheed (360) Not sure if this counts because it's not a broken game, but it's a 9/10 game IMO, that just got bad reviews because it's 4 hours long.

Can't think of anything else off the top of my head.

I've never seen the argument against short games :|