By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
richardhutnik said:

So again here, if Hitchens is correct in that, there is NO act anyone needs any God for to do, that is right, then exactly why do people fall short?

You keep saying "if". There is no if. He is undeniably correct that non-believers can be just as moral as believers. He is equally correct that people have done incredibly wicked things in the name of God which they would otherwise have had a difficult time justifying.

Is your question where morality comes from if not from God?