ICO at 102 and Final Fantasy Tactics at 87 hurt my feelings. Final Fantasy VI and Suikoden 2 also made me wince. I would love to have seen Fallout 3 higher, though I was content with the placement of Valkyria Chronicles. The lack of Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec left me speechless. No Soulcalibur, either, though I guess that's understandable considering that it was a Dreamcast game.
I was under the impression that the registration for the 2012 even was over?
Nope. Sign Ups are over on January 1st I suppose. The "deadline" was only to get people thinking about their top 50's and to have fun discussing one game at a time. But you're always welcome to start late.