By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Wonktonodi on 14 February 2011
Edit Thread
Hephaestos said:
snip


whatever your reasoning, killing someone you think is town is illogical. Even if you say it won't hurt the days we have, that is wrong. A no lynch is in effect a half day, so if the doc (if there is one) saves someone, then there is indeed an extra day of play sprining from this no lynch.

Killing someone you think is town really has no benefits. The only one you pointed isn't even true, all players can be manipulated and make mistakes, linkz is the example for last round, the "I healed linkz day 2 and 3" was a direct attempt at buddying up with him, and that most inevitably affected his judgement. I'd even say that manipulating linkz was more important than manipulating radish last round. Cause linkz could have shifted the town if he had a target in sights.

Also, you might want to further your logic by lynching the best players first... after all they are the most likely to be good at hiding in sheep's clothes and their backstabs would be the most deadly and yet stelthy to the town. At least here you don't lynch someone you think is townie, as the player quality is independent from his random role.

Oh and don't worry, Radish isn't cleared by a longshot.

First I have never said I thought he was town.  Only that I was neutral on him. I've never seen a game with a doc so I don't know how often those actually happen.

Next there was more than one point.  So saying I only have one isn't true.  I don't know why you are not noticing the other points I've made. You are good enough a player to have noticed them so I think something else is going on.  However since people seem to forget. One thing he did was  hammering without noticing that he's doing it.  Once would be bad enough, but he did it twice in a row.  The other point was how he was inactive after being a confirmed mason.  This was before his computer had problems because one point when linkz called him out on it he came it back really quick and voted without much information along with the vote.

That tactic seems to work better for scum.  IE your first day lynch last game after being MVP. You take out enough good players then they might miss something they wouldn't had more of them been left since the weaker players don't notice as much.  I really don't see how having strong players can hurt the town while having weaker ones can. Plus once again I've never said I think he's townie.

For instance although you are a stronger player you either not noticing or more likely choosing to leave out the other points I made, plus your bad math moment are really suspicios.If you were a weaker player I could see it happening but not so much from you.

HOS Heph