VGC Mafia Round 25

[Linkzmax]

One thing I did notice in a quick skim is radish's vote, so I'd like to comment on that first before a more in-depth read.

A Bad Clown said:

radishhead said:

radishhead said:

A Bad Clown said:

radishhead said:

Strange turn of events - don't forget that I haven't actually been suspicious this game - the only time that I've been mentioned is where Wonk was picking me out as an example of a player that we could lynch to get the numbers down. You can ask me whatever, but I don't have much to say.

Why do you think Wonk didn't suggest anyone else though?

He suggested a few, after he realised that singling out me was a mistake.

Not only this, but he admitted that he didn't have any grounds to be suspicious of me, and merely made misguided remarks about the last game, which Linkz was quick to put right. Nobody could have saw that coming last game - that's why nen was given the MVP, for pulling it off so well. 

In my opinion, the way that you've managed to divert suspicion off yourself by targeting another player that has had their name mentioned a few times seems considerably more suspicious. Maybe you should have done the research, and actually realised that there was nothing going on there at all.

Vote: A Bad Clown

Now that doesn't seem suspicious at all...

In isolation, no I don't think the vote is suspicious. On the other hand, I don't think the reasoning is all that great. I don't see what else you should be doing. You seemed to handle the pressure fairly well and then moved back to scumhunting, and I think you and Wonk has been the only other major subject that jumps out with some players missing in action now becoming more apparent. What I mean by that is the conversation you've had with prof leaves me thinking along the lines that he seems to be thinking, which is there was a misunderstanding(more on this later) and then it escalated into a big deal about your playing experience. Your posting has gotten more serious, which I prefer over the joking; however, I still can't follow all of your logic, so I'm certainly going to go over your story with a fine-toothed comb to see if it adds up. At the moment I get the feeling that you're a distracting townie and I'll be fine with ignoring you for the most post, unless my investigation leads me to thinking you're scum and then I'll be adding my vote to the tally for you to be lynched.

In the grand scheme of things, I had been wondering if there'd be a "tipping point" vote on you. Specifically I've been thinking "why hasn't the lynch been pushed further after trashleg's vote." If you are a townie I was thinking scum would try to work in a vote sooner, unless there's already one or two votes on you but I don't really get that impression of the voters. This would make me a bit more suspicious of radish, but only slightly because I could be wrong about the others. If you are mafia I was thinking your scummates would either try to persuade the lynch away from you, ala Heph, or would've thought you're a sinking ship and would've bailed on you already with a vote. Now seems like it'd be an odd time to give up on you though, so I'd be less suspicious of radish if you're lynched and flip scum. So in the end, I'd only see it as suspicious if you, noname, FF, and trashleg are all townies, which seems quite improbable to me.

Alright, time to get cracking on what will likely be a looooong post. Hopefully I'll be able to multi-quote, but I plan on using links mostly to cut down on size.