theRepublic said:
A town mis-lynch is worse than a mafia kill? You're going to have to explain that one. I'm really interested. My take: Let me preface this by saying that mis-lynches are bad, bad things to be avoided. However, I'll take one any day of the week over a mafia kill. When trying to lynch someone, we at least have a chance of getting mafia. A mafia kill has zero chance of getting mafia, unless we have multiple mafia factions (unlikely in this game). We also have a public record of the mis-lynch. We know who supported it, who was against it, who barely commented on it. All that information can be used later in the game. A mafia kill is done in secret. We don't know the reasoning, and it can be difficult to parse. It could be the murdered person was on the right track, it could be to make someone else look guilty, it could be to get rid of a historically strong player, it could be to get rid of someone the town thinks is innocent, it could be to get rid of a talkative player, it could be that the mafia thought that player had a strong power role, etc. That is why I prefer the town maintain all the killing power it can. |
I was getting worried nobody would ask me to clarify that statement.
First of all, my statement was aimed at Day One mislynches, especially a Day One like the one we're experiencing in the current game. Nobody has made a slip up like SM128 in the previous game, nobody has said anything overly suspicious, so us lynching someone is basically playing russian roulette with 10 out of 13 chances of killing one of our own.
Then Day Two arrives and we've got nothing to go on because we lynched a random townie just for the sake of it.
Signature goes here!








