By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

To begin.

ZenFoldorVGI said:

It seems to me that, for far too long, we've been getting very excited about the prospect of this console "not sucking."
Not so. This creates the false expectation that up to this point the Playstation 3 has "sucked", not only to its detractors but to the people who support it.

Few reasonable detractors have ever claimed that the system sucked. Perhaps that its value differential versus its price differential did not justify its purchase instead of a 360, sure (I have said that myself), but not that the PS3 sucked.

No supporters of the system would acknowledge that they would celebrate the PS3 "not sucking", because this implies that there was a space of time in which one would say that the PS3 did suck. This is not going to be true for the vast majority of people, much less the people for whom the PS3 is the platform of choice.
Early this gen, many of us pretty much wrote it off, but it made a comeback. It didn't become an epic console. Basically, it just started to not suck.
I'm going to take a moment to ponder over this. Just for a second.

Firstly, you are going to need to define "wrote off", as you say later on in your post that expectations for the PS3 were initially high and they undoubtedly remained high for some time.

Secondly, you're going to have to qualify in what way the console previously sucked. You speak of a comeback in terms of quality, but in what way has the qualitative shift of its library been any different from its competitors? If this is not the metric to which you refer, then what the Hell are you talking about?
Unfortunately, we're treating the PS3's ability to not suck, as if it won the superbowl. Here are just a few specific examples of this fanbased ignorance:
This isn't what ignorance means. Ignorance means to lack knowledge of something, not to have a qualitative opinion that runs contrary to your own, and not a rationalization of a given set of facts. Ignorance implies that one is simply unaware of a given set of facts!

Using ignorance in that way is insulting, but it's also incorrect, which makes it unintentionally hilarious.
A. We get excited because the PS3's software sales are "starting to catch up to the 360."
This is a point on which to be excited! If there is any point on which to be excited, it is this one, because if the gap is closing between the PS3 and one of the best by-the-unit software movers in the history of the industry, it implies that the PS3 is still an economically viable platform, which means it will get more games! do not try to belittle this, because for people who want more games, it is awesome.
B. We get super-pumped over the biggest console exclusive for the PS3 selling 4 million LTD.
To the best of my knowledge, people get super pumped over the qualities of games, not the the sales numbers, but even if people get pumped about those numbers you are stripping this sentiment of context and meaning. Try "We get super-pumped about the biggest selling console exclusive being on-track to outsell at least one of its predecessors on a fraction of the userbase". You would be at least in the neighborhood of the truth, then.
C. We call the big three AAA exclusive games on the PS3 "the best games in their genre," and/or "the best game/s of all time."
So? Have you failed to notice that console supporters for every console say this? Hell, I do it all the time, though not based on metacritic. Super Mario Galaxy is the best platformer I've ever played. Ninja Gaiden II has the best combat mechanics of any hack and slash ever. Metal Gear Solid 4 as a stealth action game is the best title in its genre. What is wrong with these statements?

Nothing. Nothing is wrong with them.
D. We flame multiplatform games, if they don't sell well on the PS3, despite their quality, like Bioshock. We also make up conditions as to why certain didn't meet expectations(ie: "sold well for a new IP" or "sold well for February" ect.)
Wait, who on Earth is "we"?

Qualifiers need to be added for all games sales, because no set of numbers occurs in a vacuum.
This generation is very polarizing and its very sad to see that in most cases, this bias has spread through the veins of most videogame entheusiast reporters.
Wait, this is about reporters? Or is that just an aside which has nothing to do with the rest of anything?
Now, there are a few things we need to remember about the PS3 before we start clamoring over how great the console has done this generation, by pulling itself out of the muck that it started from:
what muck are you referring to, here?
1. The console still has very poor Jrpg support by any standard. This is a travesty we can place directly on Sony's head.
What? No. No. No. The JRPG support isn't as good as that of the 360 or the wii, but are you forgetting what Sega consoles used to look like on this front? Or the original Xbox? Or the Gamecube?

How can this be blamed on Sony? Because they... what? Aren't paying for exclusives? Is that what you mean to imply? It can't be because they created a hostile programming environment, JRPGs have never been that complex in the first place and Square seems to do all right. See, that bothers me: you say that we can blame Sony for this, and then you qualify this statement not at all.
2. Sony has decided to no longer support 3rd party exclusive games, instead concentrating on its first and second party party, admittedly western-centric titles, at cost to Sony fans, with profits as a motive. This is in stark contrast to the gamer-centric strategy of Sony's main competition. The Lost and the Damned, for instance, is a AAA loss likely due directly to Sony's cheapness.
The worst part of this is how much it doesn't make sense. Yeah, I feel confident saying that.

How did Sony "support" third party efforts in the past? To the best of my knowledge they've never funded them, and the furthest they went in the PS1 era was promoting FFVII in the West, which was not actually a financially sound move!

Another part here is that you're placing profits as a motive in a necessarily negative context, which is disingenuous when we are talking about a business. Applying moral standards to "profit" vs. "gamer-centric" is absurd.
This has also led to the loss of every major 3rd party Playstation brand associated game, from DMC to FFXIII, to Tekken, as well as a wealth of DLC.
Which is hilarious in that two thirds of the games you named weren't originally associated with the Playstation anyway. Third parties know no loyalty.

And how do you think Sony was supposed to stop them, exactly? Spend money they didn't have to secure rights?
3. The PS3 is still on pace to easily end up in 3rd place this gen, and in fact, it is almost impossible mathematically to come up with any scenerio which would keep the PS3 out of dead last. The PS3 lost this generation. The gamecube also, didn't suck.
All right this is fine, yeah... Wait.
The gamecube also, didn't suck.
What the Hell does this have to do with the price of tea in China?

These are hurting my brain!
4. Even if it didn't lose this generation, which it did, the console still went from the most epic of wins, the PS2, to a degredation of its namesake, the near ruination of the Playstation brand, and all of this is attributed directly to Sony's attempt to push early adoption of Blu-Ray at the expense of its gaming fanbase.
Nothing particularly wrong here: most of the woes of the PS3 can probably be blamed on blu-ray.
4. The console still costs 399 dollars. This, above all else, is an unacceptable fiasco.
No, that's economics, and it's apparently acceptable to literally millions and millions of people who see a value differential greater than the price differential.

I mean come on. "Fiasco"?
5. The console is still significantly behind in game library according to the quantifiable methods of determination, aggregate reviews and/or overall game sales. This is an admittedly weak point, but still, it's the only quantifiable methods we have to determine such things as game library quality and more importantly, game library popularity.
There are no objective measures of quality in any artistic medium, this point holds no merit whatsoever. It isn't just weak.

Popularity is more important than perceived quality? Since when, exactly?
6. HOME has been underwhelming, and XBL is still the superior online service by most accounts, despite huge steps Sony has taken to make the services equal.
....For free.
7. Sony actually and purposefully removed Backwards Compatibility, in what we can only assume was an attempt to sell more Playstation 2s. This is an insult to all consumers, and equivelant to a price hike.
Actually, it was probably for the sake of moving PS3 software. Equating any kind of business decision with an "insult" to consumers is, again, completely ridiculous.
These, however, aren't the dominant claims of a winning console.
It does not have to win in order to be great. It does not have to win in order to be celebrated.
These are the braggotries of a console's fanbase, discussing a console which many expected to suck, but which actually ended up not sucking.
....I'm not entirely sure what the first clause here is supposed to mean.

People didn't expect the PS3 to suck. They expected it to dominate. That's why it has failed to meet expectations in some circles.
Just remember this console's position. Not everyone is as entheuiastic as you are about it, but that doesn't mean it's a bad console, however, in an effort to prove it doesn't suck, most of you hype it as the second coming. This isn't the Playstation 1.
Don't go reminding people that opinions are subjective and then try to imply that there's an objective standard of limitations in terms of how they may celebrate their own perceptions of the console. You will end up tripping over your own feet from crossing them so much.
The PS3 doesn't suck.

Celebrating that is fine, but let's not go overboard.
You are in exactly no position to make any kind of value judgement as to how much celebration of this particular console is appropriate or not.
Flamers, if you must....get to it.
Let me make sure I got this straight.

You came in here to say that the Playstation doesn't suck, but it isn't fantastic like everyone lieks to pretend. The reason for this is that Sony has abandoned the gamers, and you have somehow equated business decisions concerning the penetration of new hardware with a moral scale which precludes using one piece of technology as a Trojan horse for another, which is exactly what the PS2 was, too.

Then you go on to say that, hey, at least you didn't say the PS3 sucked, so at least you aren't flaming, right fellas? Right?

This topic doesn't actually have any message to it, no single cohesive thread of logic that binds it all together. This is a bunch of disassociated statements of barely tenable quality or accuracy whose only relation to each other is that they're meant to rile people up.