The doctor wont roleclaim, he will get killed if he does. Theres nothing more than to assume he protected WoW.
The doctor wont roleclaim, he will get killed if he does. Theres nothing more than to assume he protected WoW.
trangentspree said:
So you think it's fine to just assume who the Doctor protected Night 1? |
No, I think we shouldn't because it gives us no info. There were three mafia kills. That would mean three different mafia factions. If that's so, then whoever the doctor protected wasn't targeted, barring a possible SK kill we can't know yet. Therefore, asking who of the more than 20 possible people was the target of the doctor protection is completely useless
trangentspree said:
Put yourself in our shoes: You claim you're going to die Night 2. We don't investigate you Night 2. You don't die Night 2 and we still have no idea whether you're to be trusted or not in Day 3. At least if you're investigated Night 2, whatever the outcome, we will know what alignment you are and whether we are to trust anything you have said so far. |
I think that is a likely scenario. I think it's entirely possible that all 3 (?) mafia groups and the vigilante/SK will decide not to kill me tonight.
If/when that happens, you can do whatever the heck you want. I'll be a doing a happy dance.
ArkZero said: The doctor wont roleclaim, he will get killed if he does. Theres nothing more than to assume he protected WoW. |
I agree with this. So ArkZero, do you agree with me that the Doctor should protect dtewi (the Cop) now that he has roleclaimed?
Son1x said:
Oh wow, I didn't even notice that. You want the doctor to role-claim? vote: trangentspree |
I'm not asking that the doctor roleclaim, or that we lynch WoW. I merely want the town to consider that WoW is asking us to presume she is a townie and follow her lead without proving otherwise.
With a Cop's confirmation that she is innocent, I'll find this easier to accept.
Words Of Wisdom said:
I agree with this. So ArkZero, do you agree with me that the Doctor should protect dtewi (the Cop) now that he has roleclaimed? |
I completely agree with this, lets see if the doctor takes in count these comments.
ArkZero said:
I completely agree with this, lets see if the doctor takes in count these comments. |
So we haven't seen much of your posts up until now (or at least I haven't been paying attention to them), so what are your thoughts? And more importantly, are you enjoying yourself so far?
Words Of Wisdom said:
So we haven't seen much of your posts up until now (or at least I haven't been paying attention to them), so what are your thoughts? And more importantly, are you enjoying yourself so far? |
Well, my main suspects right now are trangentspree (for wanting the doctor to roleclaim) and Zexen (for being aggressive).
Im enjoying the game so far, I didnt post a lot because this is my first game and at first I didnt know how to play.
ArkZero said:
Well, my main suspects right now are trangentspree (for wanting the doctor to roleclaim) and Zexen (for being aggressive). Im enjoying the game so far, I didnt post a lot because this is my first game and at first I didnt know how to play. |
I think everyone has been there. A lot of the people you see talking right now were pretty darn quiet at the beginning of their first few games as well but it gets easier if you talk a bit more.
Just remember that the more you post and the more open about your opinions you are the more helpful you'll be to the town. With what looks like three mafia families running around, there's a lot of scum in the waters around here so don't be afraid to point out something that looks kind of odd to you.
Also, it looked like a couple deaths last night were semi-lurkers so if those people are out to kill lurkers then being active and contributing might help you live a little longer. Welcome to mafia. ^_^
Not me! I was the most active guy around on my first game.
Then it went downhill