By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 14 - Game Thread

zexen_lowe said:
SciFiBoy said:
trangentspree said:

@ScifiBoy

im gonna die anyway, why not go out in a different way

If you wanna go out with a bang, I can always permaban you, my banhammer always needs someone to fall on. And you'll certainly be removed from the game afterwards

im okay thanks, I like the great moderation record I have on my account



Around the Network
SciFiBoy said:
zexen_lowe said:
SciFiBoy said:
trangentspree said:

@ScifiBoy

im gonna die anyway, why not go out in a different way

If you wanna go out with a bang, I can always permaban you, my banhammer always needs someone to fall on. And you'll certainly be removed from the game afterwards

im okay thanks, I like the great moderation record I have on my account

That offense you have from February 9 is pretty heavy...you must be proud of it




VGChartzville clamber around ScifiBoy with pitchforks and scythes in hand. SHTUNG, off flies an arm. SHWUACK, there goes what was once his functional and attached legs. SHPLAT, and with the last swipe there goes ScifiBoy's manhood. At the orgy of blood and entrails the townspeople dance in a drunken stupor, until someone accidentally drives a fork straight into Zexen's face. He dies instantly, with an expression of sedated joy spread across his face.

In the distance, a silhoutted figure fires a massiveass missle at the group of frolickers. First the ground catches fire, then their clothes, then their skin. In the end nothing remains but a mound of ashen terran. The sceen pans up to above the hidden figure in the distance, where some writing is being scrawled across the sky in blood...

 

Day 8 ends!

TRANGENTSPREE WINS!



zexen_lowe said:
SciFiBoy said:
zexen_lowe said:
SciFiBoy said:
trangentspree said:

@ScifiBoy

im gonna die anyway, why not go out in a different way

If you wanna go out with a bang, I can always permaban you, my banhammer always needs someone to fall on. And you'll certainly be removed from the game afterwards

im okay thanks, I like the great moderation record I have on my account

That offense you have from February 9 is pretty heavy...you must be proud of it

lol, what? the warning for sig length?



c03n3nj0 said:
Falcon095 said:
SciFiBoy said:
trangentspree said:

Especially when all the lurkers had power roles, that held up the nighttime as well. It must have been horrible to moderate that.

I think there just needs to be zero tolerance for lurking - a mafia-ban for people who signed up for the game and then did nothing with no given excuse, and a backup list to replace players that leave or get removed.

the rules of the game should also apply to everyone, so if you die, you stay dead, unless your role allows otherwise.


This. If you modkill somebody for doing X, unless it makes the game unbalanced, you must kill everybody who does that too. If you revived a player from 1 team, you need to revive another player of the other team too.

But it would'nt have made sense if he revived a mafia with dsister because we already knew he was cop. That's an instant death for the revived person. 

Even in games where we didn't know who was the good guy, it would narrow it down to two persons instantly.

I'm guessing a back-up list for players would be useful at that point, then the swapping could be done in secret... for anti or pro-town...

Well, obviously you won't revive somebody whose role has been already revealed or you won't revive somebody that was a mafia, that back-up list would be the best thing to do.



||Tag courtesy of fkusumot - "Heaven is like a Nintendo theme park!"||Join the Medal of Honor: Heroes 2 American League HERE!||

Around the Network
Final-Fan said:
Look you guys, there's plenty to complain about regarding this game (even if TOS isn't to blame for it) but your specific complaint of
-- choice of dsister for the replacement of dtewi
is just laughable IMO. You can complain about the fact that the cop was one of only two people to get a replacement, but complaining about dsister being the one to replace him is just dumb IMO. dsister had ZERO information about the game, just his observations. Unless he had non-kosher information (like being a mafia/mason/talking to other dead people with such info) I fail to see the difference between him getting the role and some other person who had not been in the game at all.

Falcon -- dsister did not get "revived".

Personally IMO this game was a disaster but very little of that can be laid at TOS's feet. When half the players quit, it's really their fault for the problems that creates.

No, I'm not complaining about dsister being the one that replaced dtewi, the action itself is my complain. When I mentioned that dsister being the one made it worse I meant that dsister was a player that was already dead and it's unfair to other dead players to chose him, I mean, I'm pretty sure that SFB wanted to get in back in the game again. Whenever an action like that is done it should be a person who wasn't in the game.



||Tag courtesy of fkusumot - "Heaven is like a Nintendo theme park!"||Join the Medal of Honor: Heroes 2 American League HERE!||

c03n3nj0 said:
SciFiBoy said:
c03n3nj0 said:
Too lazy to quote you scifi, and chrome sucks sooo

1. But dtewi was active, unlike the mafia members who got modkilled. It's way worse to lose an active player than someone who's dead weight anyway, wouldn't you agree?

2. Okay, let's say he didn't choose dsister? Who would be there to replace him that hasn't played yet? Would the mod just stop the game so he could search for someone who was willing to play? No, they all already signed up in the beginning of the game.

And besides, dsister was the only one of ya that said he was available.

1. so what? he said he could no longer play (therefore making him inactive from that point on)

2. given what had happend before then, in this game, the mod should have modkilled dtwei

3. I dont recall being asked or even having it suggested to me, I have been both online and keeping fairly up to date with this game since I died, though I dont ask to cheat and go back in as I respect the rules.

1. What do you mean so what? He was active through the game. For example seraphic didn't even play from the get-go, he's basically dead weight that won't help his mafia family at all. 

dtewi, was doing something at least, it would've hurt the town more to lose him. The only reason the mafia got hurt was because nearly half of them weren't playing at all. I guess no one would've cared if they were townies....

2. Someone was replaced already? Okay, why would he modkill dtewi then? And besides, I'm usre the person who got filled in already had the intention of playing. 

3. Silly point, it would've bene useless to ask you.

1- I understan that DBN, darth and serapic getting modkilled, but lestatdark was as active as dtewi and arkzero when he was here, and yet neither got modkilled. You all are missing the point of the complains, We are not complaining that Truck modkilled them, we are complaining that the modkills weren't for all the teams, like I said, lestatdark was as active as dtewi and arkzero, he told truck that he had problems just like dtewi, and yet he got modkilled, dtewi got replaced by dsister and arkzero continued to play. That was the problem.

2- Maybe because there were 3 mafia modkilled?



||Tag courtesy of fkusumot - "Heaven is like a Nintendo theme park!"||Join the Medal of Honor: Heroes 2 American League HERE!||

lestatdark didn't have problems, he was going on vacation for 2 weeks.



Signature goes here!

TruckOSaurus said:

Night Action Table:

 


Voting To Lynch ( Popular )
Person Role Night 1
Night 2 Night 3 Night 4 Night 5 Night 6
ArkZero Doctor WoW dtewi dtewi ---- ---- ----
dtewi Cop SciFiBoy zexen_lowe KingFate theRepublic Falcon095 trangentspree
trangentspree Serial Killer supermario128 dgc1808 WoW theRepublic Son1x KingFate
Words of Wisdom Alcoholic Nightwatchman Watch WoW Hide 1 of 3 Hide 2 of 3 Hide 3 of 3 ---- ----
Corleone Family Night Kill Final-Fan WoW ArkZero ---- ---- ----
Tattaglia Family Night Kill dsister44 SciFiBoy Vetteman WoW dsister44 ----

 

I was popular!  Woo hoo!



To keep things going I made a sign up thread for the next game:

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/thread.php?id=104158

Presently the game is "host-less" so if anyone wants to step up. Here's your chance!



Signature goes here!