Hey man, I hear that, I hated Tomb Raider games as well (pretty boring to me). Uncharted 1 failed to impress me as well (I felt I was watching a very long, slow (and boring) movie, not playing a game). I haven't played U2 yet though, so who knows, maybe I'll be a believer as well.

@outlaw, if someone hates a game it's completely reasonable for them to think it's not a good game, even if he or she is alone in that thought in the entire world. Whether a game is a good game is usually dependent on your own tastes, there is no universal rating system, and such a thing is probably impossible.

Very much correct in terms of sheer quality--the single player game is second to none and probably the best single player game I've played since Half Life 2.

I have to say i enjoyed AC2 more, but id accept Batman, NSMB, UC2 or AC2 as great choices for any GOTY awards.

I wholeheartedly agree with their decision, Uncharted 2 is a very special game, it definitely makes itself stand out from the other games made this year.
As for AC2 I really did not like the first one, so I could not really comment on AC2.