TruckOSaurus said:
trashleg said:
sabby_e17 said:
What do you mean?
I think the only person that role claimed was Zexen and he was the cop.
|
that was aimed at Trucks. what i meant was, nobody else has roleclaimed doctor so we don't have any reason to doubt Carl, for now at least.
|
Read this http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=2899553 to see why I don't think a doctor would call his bluff.
|
i guess, but then why would Carl roleclaim in the first place if he wasnt the doctor? because now surely he'll be the prime target for the mafia.. the way i see it, there are only three possibilities...
1. desperate attempt to be saved from lynching (not all that likely, sinceit wasnt like his life depended on it)
2 diverting attention away from whoever the REAL doctor is, allowing the doctor to perform his task for one more night (i guess this could be true, since he admitted that his heart hasnt been in this game)
3. he IS the doctor.
whichever way you look at it, whether he's lying or not, i dont think he's mafia. because now, why WOULDN'T the mafia target him tonight? THE DOCTOR IS THEIR BIGGEST OBSTACLE. but then if he's still alive tomorrow, either A) he's mafia or B) the mafia didnt target him to make it look like he's mafia.
in fact, why did he roleclaim at all?
each possibility leads onto more and more branched possibilites... >.<;