By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Rare Project Natal Game Cancelled: "Undisclosed Prototype" in Works for 1 Year

HappySqurriel said:

Microsoft didn’t kill Rare, and you could argue that they were the victim in the situation ...

In the late 90s, Rare's success caused every major studio and publisher to attempt to poach Rare's talent away from them; and in general, they were highly successful. As this continued, Rare's games were seeing longer and longer delays and (it could be argued) were lower and lower quality; and Nintendo was spening more and more time managing Rare to get products out the door. The Stamper Bros wanted to retire off of the equity in Rare and offered to sell the studio to Nintendo, who didn't believe that it was worth what they were asking and declined.

Microsoft needed a well known first party studio and foolishly bought the controlling interest in Rare from the Stamper Bros. and then Nintendo sold their stake in Rare to Microsoft as well. Since then, Rare has only released a handful of games and very few of them have been particularly good or sold well.


The best analogy to the situation is that Microsoft bought a used sports car and found out it was a Lemon upon delivery

A lemon upon delivery? Rare maintained its staff fairly well untill around 06, the Stamper Brothers remained on board and many other leading developers were their untill the beginning of this generation. Fact is Microsoft ruined Rare, many of the former amazing staff left Rare awhile after Microsoft took over, forming their own studios or going to work for other companies.

Under Microsoft Rare has yet to release a true jaw dropping game as they did for Nintendo on multiple occasions. The closest would have to be PerfectDark on the 360 but even that wasn't up to Rare's history of AAA+ titles. Fact is after buying Rare Microsoft drove most of the former staff to quit, this is fully Microsoft's fault.

The origional analogy that Microsoft killed Rare is true. If Nintendo had remained in charge Rare would probubly still be a great notable developer. But once Microsoft took over it all went down hill!



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer

 

Around the Network

lol @Joelcool

Perfet dark Zero is their best game since leaving Nintendo? And both of the studios that formed out of Rare happened before they were bought by Microsoft. And lets look at what those studios have accomplished One is out of business =O, and one makes crappy puzzle games =O yeah they lost their best devs.



Is there a reason as to why I can't get here from the main page? It just has a little picture of the OP and says: 33 replies (0 new) (last page), started by: Lastgengamer

WTF?

OT: Rare needs to make another Banjo game like the ones on the N64. Platforming hub-world games = !!!



Rareware was the first party studio that stood out SO well during the N64 era.. now theyre dead to me :(



Currently playing: MAG, Heavy Rain, Infamous

 

Getting Plat trophies for: Heavy Rain, Infamous, RE5,  Burnout and GOW collection once I get it.

 

patapon said:
Is there a reason as to why I can't get here from the main page? It just has a little picture of the OP and says: 33 replies (0 new) (last page), started by: Lastgengamer

WTF?

OT: Rare needs to make another Banjo game like the ones on the N64. Platforming hub-world games = !!!


same problem



Currently playing: MAG, Heavy Rain, Infamous

 

Getting Plat trophies for: Heavy Rain, Infamous, RE5,  Burnout and GOW collection once I get it.

 

Around the Network

Rareware was not 1st party.



Edit: I see what you mean now 



dsister44 said:
gamelover2000 said:
patapon said:
Is there a reason as to why I can't get here from the main page? It just has a little picture of the OP and says: 33 replies (0 new) (last page), started by: Lastgengamer

WTF?

OT: Rare needs to make another Banjo game like the ones on the N64. Platforming hub-world games = !!!


same problem

I don't think so. That would entail you buying a 360


did you mean me or Patapon? as he owns one and I meant the part about the thread not opening as it should..



Currently playing: MAG, Heavy Rain, Infamous

 

Getting Plat trophies for: Heavy Rain, Infamous, RE5,  Burnout and GOW collection once I get it.

 

dsister44 said:
lol @Joelcool

Perfet dark Zero is their best game since leaving Nintendo? And both of the studios that formed out of Rare happened before they were bought by Microsoft. And lets look at what those studios have accomplished One is out of business =O, and one makes crappy puzzle games =O yeah they lost their best devs.

No. Conker: Live & Reloaded is their best game since leaving Nintendo. Perfect Dark Zero doesn't looks like Perfect Dark 64, Banjo Nuts & Bolts is a good game but it's a crap if we compare with the n64 versions. Let's face it, "Rare" is just the name now but they aren't the same people who made Banko Kazooie, Perfect Dark (n64), Killer Instinct etc. They aren't the same developers... not even the design for Banjo is the same, look at his face.... LOOK AT KAZOOIE T__T

 

This is the real Banjo and Kazooie:

Not even the designer is the fu* same! T___________T *crying*

I am sorry, I am just... sorry... I am a little emotive. :(



I would actually have to say that their best game since leaving Nintendo has to be Viva Pinata.