Some of you are complaining about borderlands unjustifiably. The game rules. Geometry wars however doesn't need to be on this list. Part 2 is much much better...

ODSt is a little too high. Completely agree with halo wars as well.

gow 1 and 2, halo 3, gta IV, call of duty 4 and bioshock are all somewhere in the top ten without a doubt

Updated today. Looks like no Fable II as I predicted. Also, The top five will probably compose of Gears of War 2, Fallout 3, Mass Effect, Grand Theft Auto IV, and I don't know, maybe Oblivion can sneak in there. It will probably be RPG domination.

What about CoD 4 :/

Something's wrong...

Oblivion has to be on that list. But then CoD 4 too...

And no Batman: AA...argh!

I can't believe they added Lost Odyssey, Virtua Fighter 5 and Halo Wars to that list...it's kind of stupid.

Fable II > Lost Odyssey
Street Fighter IV and BlazBlue > Virtua Fighter 5

And no Resident Evil 5! :O
It might not be a true Resident Evil game but it was still very good.

VF5 is quite a game. You may not be in to the fighting but its by far the deepest fighter available. The fact it had flawless online and came out 2 years before the 2 games you mentioned makes it stand out.

Have you played them? Both Lost Odyssey and Halo Wars were two of the best games of this gen 

No but I'm basing myself on the score they gave to the games. " > " means that they gave the game an higher score.

Fable II (8.8/10) - Lost Odyssey (8.2/10) huh?

Virtua Fighter 5 (9/10) - Street Fighter IV (9.3/10) - BlazBlue (9.4/10) huh? again

What's the goal of giving a score to a game if it doesn't represent how good it is?

Oops, forgot about CoD 4. It'll almost definitely get the nod over Oblivion, though I don't get how that didn't make the list either.