By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Uncharted vs Gears

GB Face-Off: Gears of War vs Uncharted

GB Face-Off is our new weekly feature which will be carried out every week from now on, where we will put all the biggest gaming rivalries under test and try to set the records straight once and for all. You can also suggest us what you want to see in the next Face-Off and we’ll try to pull that off…fairly. Ok guys time to start off this thing. So here goes our first Face-Off.


There is no denying that Gears of War and Uncharted have been star AAA new IPs for both Xbox 360 and PS3 respectively. Both titles have created the greatest buzz and have been system sellers. Now we here thought to put these games face to face and see which one is the ultimate King of the Kings. We’ll judge both these franchises under three different scales and the one winning on two of them will be our winner. So without any delay lets start our first ever GB Face-Off.

  • Characters:

Who kicks more @$$ with ease?

  • Gears of War: In Gears of War, you assume the role of Marcus Fenix, a former prisoner and war-hardened soldier. This dude defines the word bad-ass, literally. He fights hordes upon hordes of locusts without any fear or sense of mercy. He takes cover, times his moves tactically and takes down the enemies with ease. And when he goes out of ammo…then that becomes a nightmare for locusts coz that means CHAINSAW time. One of the most awesome oh-snap moments this generation right there.
  • Uncharted: Uncharted features the journey of protagonist Nathan Drake, supposed descendant of the explorer Sir Francis Drake. Now this guy has got some moves. He’ll come at you from places, of which you’ll have no idea. He can jump from impossible places, stealth kill you, use his large variety of weapons and take you out one on one. In other words when you are up against Nate, you can never feel safe.
  • Verdict: Although both characters are my personal favorites. But when it comes to intense level of bad-ass-ness, combined with sheer level of believability and sense of charm-ness, Nathan Drake gets our nod. He is without any doubt one of the most lovable characters this generation.
  • Sales and Scores:

Its about $$$!!!

  • Gears of War: Gears of War was the most hyped Xbox 360 title back in 2006, when it was first released. And it lived up to all the expectations. It won great praise from critics and it sales also sky rocketed. With original Gears scoring 94 and its sequel 93 on metacritic, meant it was right on target. Both Gears of War titles have also sold above 11M combined, till date.
  • Uncharted: Uncharted was also a much hyped PS3 exclusive. And it didn’t disappoint either. Although first Uncharted title didn’t score that high on meta, with average score of 88 but its sequel met with amazing critical acclaim with a meta score of 96. However the sales paled in comparison, with original Uncharted selling just over 2.5M and although it’s been just over 2 weeks since Uncharted 2 was released but initial trends(1.1M so far) show it will be tough to better 4M-5M.
  • Verdict: Uncharted 2 has just released so it’s a bit unfair comparing its sales with Gears of War but still there is no doubt its highly unlikely that it will outsell Gears. So Gears of War with average Meta of 93.5 of both titles up against Uncharted’s 92, and far above all time sales means Gears of War takes this part of Face-Off fair and square.
  • Overall Package:

King of the Kings!

  • Gears of War: When Gears of War was released back in 2006, it was without any doubt visually most stunning title anywhere. Everything from high resolution textures to high polygonal characters models was amazing. And it raised the bar again with its sequel although it wasn’t much of a leap. But still it was the best looking console game at its time. Aside from graphics, other aspects of the game were also top notch mainly the multiplayer, which added a great deal of life to the game. Presentation and sound were the other strong aspects while story was the weakest link.
  • Uncharted: Naughty Dog created an amazing new PS3 IP in the shape of Uncharted. It boasted amazing levels of graphics with the original title but it sky rocketed to new heights with the recently released sequel. Uncharted 2 raised the bar so high, in terms of production values, that it almost abused it. Everything from story, voice acting and presentation to non-stop action was of Hollywood standards. With multiplayer added, it’s one of the most complete gaming experiences out there in the market.
  • Verdict: Although Uncharted 2 released almost a year after Gears 2 so it’s a bit unfair to compare them in terms of visuals but what Naught Dog was able to pull off with Uncharted 2, we highly doubt even the might of Epic Games isn’t in the position to compete right now. So Uncharted gets our nod again on this scale too.


Around the Network

Yeah Uncharted hands down.



some comparisions shouldn't be done. Both are top notch games but they have such different styles. uncharted 1 and 2 are complete experiences all across the board. gears on the other hand is more or less a follow up to many other shooting games of late, just done much better than the others. they both are amazing though.



Which is the better franchise? Star Wars or Indiana Jones?



d21lewis said:
Which is the better franchise? Star Wars or Indiana Jones?

A close one but Star Wars.



Around the Network

^^
Jaws.

I agree with monsterone, this seems not the best comparison as the titles seem pretty dissimilar to me once you move past the TPS cover combat.



Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...

SeriousWB said:
d21lewis said:
Which is the better franchise? Star Wars or Indiana Jones?

A close one but Star Wars.

Yeah.  I guess you're right.  Both of them have fancy gunplay  and memorable enemies, but Star Wars has epic explosions, strange creatures, heroes suffering tragedy (often times, dying), fantastic technology, cool vehicles (sometimes they even ride exotic animals), mysterious enemies, surprise twists, hundreds of varied enemies onscreen at one time, and guns with chainsaws a cool black guy.  Yeah, I guess the characters in Indiana Jones are more realistic, but Star Wars is just more fun.



Good decision! Uncharted is a lot more fun then Gears. I'm actually shocked they said Nathan is cooler then Marcus. But I'm glad.

Next one should be Halo vs Killzone or have they done that already?



So far the first Gear is the best TPS I've played this gen, but things could change when I play Uncharted 2, I don't know.,



 

 

 

 

 

idk all about that but gears is one of the most underrated games this gen yes im a ps3 fan but i played the 1st one a little bit dont know much about the 2nd one

gears has local MP both co-op and deathmatch type game modes U1 doesnt even have online U2 doesnt even have offline co-op, i dont understand why it does not gears 1 came out in 06

gears was also 1st on the scene with all the TPS cover crap in 06 everything that comes out after that will always be compared to it i cant tell u how many times ive read Uncharted is a poor mans gears on the net

not to mention gears is a more mature game



                                                             

                                                                      Play Me