I though it would be interesting to match up the best of what the ps3 and Wii has to offer, and find out which top 5 you would choose. The top 5 games chosen are the ones I feel best represent the system. So you may not agree with the top 5 but that's fine, explain which top 5 you prefer and why. Feel free to compare each game separately or the top 5 itself.

Please be respectful and post sincerely.

Truly a mouthwatering list of games.

 Vs

 Vs

 Vs

 Vs

 Vs

A list of games that are out of this world, so please which top 5 you would choose and why. Please be as descriptive as possible, please no one liners. It will be interesting to find out the thoughts of the community, cheers.

As you can from my badges im as neutral as they come!

A celebration of Gaming!

Twilight Princess and Okami aren't exclusives my good sir. I'll make my list in an edit.

i would pick everything on the ps3 except Valkyria and replace it with Zelda

@monti - I changed Okami but zelda can stay there its only a port.

MGS4
The Legend of Uncharted: Twilight Thieves (I played both games, and just can't pick one over the other)
Super Paper Mario
Not too much interest in neither of them... but I'd say Metroid
Valkyria Chronicles

Hmm, maybe I'll have to buy a Wii after all ;)

(btw. for those wondering how I know about the Nintendo exclusives... I played on my brother's Wii quite a lot before he moved out)

/edit: Oh, or is this about making an own list... in this case (in no particular order):

PS3: MGS4, Uncharted 2, Valkyria Chronicles, Folklore, InFamous

Wii: Zelda: Twilight Princess, Super Paper Mario, SSBM, Super Mario Galaxy, Fire Emblem (didn't play all of these through, though)

Good contribution, much appreciated.

MGS4 - Haven't played yet :/
Uncharted 2 - No explanation required. It's just awesome.
LittleBigPlanet - Most innovative game I played this gen.
Killzone 2 - Overwhelming game.
Valkyria Chronicles - I didn't liked that much mostly because I don't like SRPGs but I can see what's great about it.

Super Mario Galaxy - Disappointing game. Good nonetheless I guess.
The Legend of Zelda: TP - Not a fan of Zelda game. It was just ok.
Super Paper Mario - It's not Paper Mario and it's not Super at all.
Metroid Prime 3 - Haven't played.
Super Smash Bros. Brawl - Good at first. Got bored really fast. Playing alone is dull.

My favorite top 5 would have to be the PS3 one.

GOW3 have nothing to worry about next year, Sony will no doubth top Uncharted 2 with GOW3 (in terms of epicness.) Zelda is the only thing Sony have to worry about for Goty 2010. I can't see Microsoft haveing any contender to dispute Sony or Nintendo next year.

1. Super Mario Galaxy
2. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
3. LittleBigPlanet
4. Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
5. Super Smash Bros. Brawl

Last "choice" was the only "hard" one. While VC was one of the 3 PS3 games I really wanted (along with Uncharted and inFamous), Brawl alone made me buy a Wii ;)

this will be hard since it has to be exclusives.

PS3:

1.)Ratchet the new one.
2.)Little Big Planet
3.)Ratchet the old one.
4.)Uncharted 2
5.)white knight story

Wii:
1.)Super Paper Mario
2.)Super Mario Galaxy
3.)Smash Brothers Brawl
4.)Super Mario Galaxy 2
5.)Tales of Graces