I used to think jrpgs had great stories when I was a teen but eventually these stories didn't drawn me in anymore and didn't seem anything special and I wondered why I kept playing these games. lol. (since it's hard to accept that you don't like something you grew up loving) Back then, it seemed like the stories, cutscenes, etc. were like a "reward" for the tedious encounters but when you stop caring about those stories and cutscenes, you just think, "If I wanted a good animu story, I'd watch animu or play a visual novel and not have to deal with the tedious, long gameplay. If I wanted great gameplay, I'd rather play another genre right now." I went back to jrpgs this spring/summer playing 6 from the backlog since I had the time to tackle them then and after that I knew that this genre just doesn't appeal to me anymore (I really liked one and there were two others that were fun but then after awhile I just wanted to get them through and it felt like a chore).
I might try spacing the hell out of jrpg playthroughs and playing them simultaneously with other games to see if that makes a difference. Could just be jrpg burnout (since I played many of them on the PS1 and through retro emulation, got bored, took a long break, played some on PS2, got bored, took a break, actually beat 6 of them on the 360, got bored, haven't touched one since August). A balanced playlist is most likely the way to go. I can't imagine how many people online play almost nothing but jrpgs for years (perhaps even over a decade) and NOT get sick of them. Meanwhile, Fable II, UFC 2009 Undisputed and BlazBlue (I normally don't like animu fighters) have been consistently fun for me recently.
Magna Carta II (a krpg but it's like a jrpg with korean MMO flavor single-player style) looks like it would be refreshing and might hold my interest for the 50 or so hours it takes so I'll probably play that when it goes to the bargain bin. In the mean time I'll probably get some of the older cheaper games I haven't got yet that I want to play.
My opinion of jrpgs is similar to my opinion of nu metal (except I look at the past jrpgs with rose-tinted nostalgia and think "what was I thinking?" at my old nu metal collection). I loved the hell out of that stuff as a teen but nowadays I can barely hold myself from bursting out in laughter after seeing the teen melodrama trailer that is Final Fantasy XIII. Stories like that aren't "deep". That's pop corn entertainment. And not even good pop corn entertainment. I'd rather watch cheesy True Blood and some good animu than play that. If I don't go "ugh" while reading the FF13 and Resonance of Fate reviews, I'll probably get those when they are cheap just because I stupidly still have faith (even though I end up getting bored of most jrpgs part-way through). I know I'm not the only one that has this sort of love/hate relationship with the genre. You see this a lot online and in real life (if you know people who grew up with jrpgs on the playstation).