My friend since I helped him out is letting me pick between the two as a reward.

Both are good games but Uncharted is amazing so I would say Uncharted.

inFamous

get uncharted its is cheaper and slightly better game, infamous will probably be cheaper around the holidays, buy it later

Okay so far it 50/50

Edit: whoops.

Uncharted is the better game. Infamous is still an ace game though. I have no clue, but my gutts tell me Uncharted

Something is telling me most people are gonna say uncharted.

Uncharted is better. Get that one.

Uncharted is more close to perfection, but the game is only 8 hours long but it has good replay value while infamous can be 25 hours long but it has weak replay value. So i would say get Uncharted and after you get hooked on it ( which you will ) get Uncharted 2, its gonna be GOTY

Rip off your friend for Infamous, since it's more expensive. Then buy Uncharted for cheap ;)