Which one are you getting this year and why? Im actually finding it hard to decide between the two. Yes, I know The Beatles songs are universally acclaimed and are arguably better than the setlist of Guitar Hero 5, but I feel GH5 may provide more challenge and variety.

The Beatles: Rock Band

or 

Guitar Hero 5

neither, Im getting LEGO Rockband

I vomit a little on the inside when i think of these games... For a guy that was there since GH1...this formula is just not fun anymore.

same can be said about mario #152 but it sells because its fun.

Am I allowed to say neither?

If I had a console that could play it, I'd be getting The Beatles Rock Band as it has the best songlist ever on a videogame. But sadly I don't.

I may be getting GH5 for PS2, but I doubt it. My bro may want it, though

These is a hard question... oh wait you said Beatles, now it all makes sense! go Beatles!

im getting both

Guitar Hero has Santana, who is God, basically. But I may just get neither, these games are kind of killing the music genre for me. I'm just not amused as much anymore. We'll see.....

Beatles: Rock Band. After that, I'll be too broke to buy much else. And I would still have to buy Batman: Arkham Asylum, Assassin's Creed 2, and probably some other game.