21 Super Mario Brothers 3 (+)

17 Super Mario World (-)

14 Super Mario RPG (-)

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine

14 New Super Mario Bros.

13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2

9 Super Mario World 2

8 Super Smash Bros. Melee

6 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
6 Mario Tennis Power Tour
6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Smash Bros.
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

2 Mario Golf Advance Tour
2 Super Mario Strikers

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

21 Super Mario Brothers 3

17 Super Mario World

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine

14 New Super Mario Bros. (-)

13 Super Mario RPG
13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2

9 Super Mario World 2

8 Super Smash Bros. Melee (+)

6 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
6 Mario Tennis Power Tour
6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Smash Bros.
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

2 Super Mario Strikers

1 Mario Golf Advance Tour (-)

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

21 Super Mario Brothers 3

17 Super Mario World

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine
15 New Super Mario Bros.

13 Super Mario RPG
13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2

9 Super Mario World 2

8 Super Smash Bros. Melee (+)

6 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
6 Mario Tennis Power Tour
6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Smash Bros.
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

0 Super Mario Strikers (-)
0 Mario Golf Advance Tour (-)

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

21 Super Mario Brothers 3

17 Super Mario World

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine

14 New Super Mario Bros. (-)
14 Super Mario RPG (+)

13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong

9 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2 (-)
9 Super Mario World 2

8 Super Smash Bros. Melee

6 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
6 Mario Tennis Power Tour
6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Smash Bros.
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

21 Super Mario Brothers 3

17 Super Mario World

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine

14 New Super Mario Bros. (-)
14 Super Mario RPG (+)

13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong

9 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
9 Super Mario World 2

7 Super Smash Bros. Melee

6 Mario Tennis Power Tour
6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

5 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour (-)

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Smash Bros.
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

20 Super Mario Brothers 3 (-)

18 Super Mario World (+)

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine

14 New Super Mario Bros.
14 Super Mario RPG

13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong

9 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
9 Super Mario World 2

7 Super Smash Bros. Melee

6 Mario Tennis Power Tour
6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

4 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour (-)
4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Smash Bros.
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

20 Super Mario Brothers 3

18 Super Mario World

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine
15 New Super Mario Bros.

14 Super Mario RPG

13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong

9 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
9 Super Mario World 2

7 Super Smash Bros. Melee (+)

6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

5 Mario Tennis Power Tour (-)

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

3 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour (-)
3 Super Smash Bros.

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

21 Super Mario Brothers 3 (+)

17 Super Mario World (-)

15 Super Mario 64
15 Paper Mario 2
15 Super Mario Sunshine
15 New Super Mario Bros.

14 Super Mario RPG

13 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong

9 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
9 Super Mario World 2

7 Super Smash Bros. Melee

6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

5 Mario Tennis Power Tour

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

3 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour

2 Super Smash Bros. (-)

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

20 Super Mario Brothers 3 (-)

17 Super Mario World

16 New Super Mario Bros. (+)

15 Super Mario 64

15 Super Mario Sunshine

14 Paper Mario 2 (-)
14 Super Mario RPG
14 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario
12 Mario Kart Double Dash!!

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong

9 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
9 Super Mario World 2

7 Super Smash Bros. Melee

6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

4 Mario Tennis Power Tour

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

2 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour

2 Super Smash Bros.

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

BTW, Mario VS. DK 1 sucked. Bad. 

20 Super Mario Brothers 3 (-)

17 Super Mario World

16 New Super Mario Bros. (+)

15 Super Mario 64

15 Super Mario Sunshine

14 Paper Mario 2 (-)
14 Super Mario RPG
14 Super Mario Kart

12 Super Paper Mario

11 Mario Kart Double Dash!! (-)
11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Kart Super Circuit

10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong

9 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
9 Super Mario World 2

8 Super Smash Bros. Melee (+)

6 Super Mario Land 2
6 Super Mario Land

4 Mario Strikers Charged
4 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
4 Super Mario Bros. 2

3 Mario Tennis Power Tour (-)

2 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
2 Super Smash Bros.

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour
6. Mario Party 7
7. Mario Party 8
8. Mario Party 6
9. Mario Party Advance
10. Mario Party 2
11. Mario Party 5
12. Mario Party 3
13. Mario Party
14. Mario Bros.
15. Mario Power Tennis
16. Mario Tennis
17. Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
18. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
19. Donkey Kong (GB)
20. Mario Kart 64
21. Donkey Kong
22. Mario Golf
23. Super Mario Strikers
24. Mario Golf Advance Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.