By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Why we need a flat tax.

Sqrl said:
MontanaHatchet said:
Slimebeast said:

Like Mafoo is saying, it's my time that is being stolen! Work work work 8 hours a day (over 10 hours if u include lunch break and transportation), do you think I am doing it voluntarily?

Im fu***ing wasting my life and getting robbed!! As a doctor in Sweden I make just a measily $54,000 a year (before taxes) after almost 10 years of experience at this work, 6 years of med school and $75,000 in student loans.

And then this myth, everyone I meet out there believes I'm wealthy because Im a doctor.

My closest relatives were unfortunate in life, so they're pretty much living off of wellfare ($800-$1000/month) and it feels so wrong that I can't afford to help them because the state is robbing $3500 off of me every month and giving it to others. $3500 worth of services that I produce by treating and helping 20 patients every day.

Instead of giving some of it to people I love I am forced to give it to leeches. Meanwhile my family gets to see the angry and irritated part of me because Im tired after work. It's so wrong.

Really? Is this the idealogy of the right? "Me, me, me?" You even emphasized this my bolding "my time," as if somehow your time were holy and special. Anyone who values their time so highly would never spent a second of it playing videogames, since that is, in the end, a waste of time. Look, my tax dollars go towards building and repairing roads that I'll never use, and giving services to people that I'll never meet. And I'm happy to do this, because I know that other people are doing the same for me. You're not being robbed, stop being so sensationalist. The people who get services like welfare aren't leeches. If you were put in the same situation, or you lost your job and you needed assistance, should people just forget about you and think of you as a leech?

It's a selfish attitude, and I don't like it.

What exactly is wrong with people looking after their own interests? Yes "MY TIME", bolded underlined and size 120 font if you like. 

You're wrong that someone who values their time so highly would never play video games.  Your mistake is in seeing the word value to mean the cash value of the time as opposed to understanding that it is the freedom of allocation that is highly valued and not just the time itself. 

Every second someone spends working unwillingly and uncompensated on another's behalf is slavery by definition. Without that "selfish" reqiurement of compensation that is exactly what it is, but you wouldn't call it "selfish" to desire not to be a slave.  And compensation is not simply a tangential benefit decided on by another, it is something the person actually wants, requests, and is agreed to before the work is done.  So to the extent that someone gets something they value for their tax dollars this is not slavery, but government corruption, waste, and yes for some even welfare...makes all of us slaves to the system and those who profit from this while others get no compensation for the money that is wasted, embezzled, etc....are made the masters of the slaves who pay those taxes. 

People need to have the proper disdain for taxes to fully appreciate the question of what kind of system we should use.  Specifically they should understand that taxation is inherently a form of national enslavement.  Every person will disagree with how their money is spent in some way.  No matter how we slice it forcing someone to work for something they don't want or even would like to prevent in many cases is slavery.  We can justify it a number of ways by, for instance, saying "Well the will of one man cannot be allowed to subvert the need of the nation." etc... But that is just another way of saying "Well tough shit...then that man will just have to be a slave to the nation."...only we phrase it in our mind in a way that allows us to sleep better.

I know some will point to democracy and say that is really what this goes back to but this ignores the distance between two points.  Specifically the points where any given man is given a vote in the booth and the point at which the policy which spends his money is actually put into effect. No man when he casts his vote has even the feintest illusion that he could control such a fine aspect of the government.  But even so, nobody votes for government waste and nobody votes for government ineffeciency so the problem persists regardless.

I'm sure this type of commentary will be found severe by many. But such is the severe reality of a tax system or really any system where a person's work is put to use for purposes out of their control.  We are told it is a necessary evil (I see alternatives) and given the political climate this is probably true.  But where I diverge from the left the most is that they seem happy with this slave and master based reality to the system...a position that, to me, defies logic.
 

PS - I'm not speaking of simply a symbolic slavery, but literal slavery - to view it any other way is fooling one's self into a false sense of comfort.

 

 

So...no tax at all then?



Tag: Became a freaking mod and a complete douche, coincidentally, at the same time.



Around the Network
Final-Fan said:

Well, if you think that it's right for us (by way of gov't) to inflict more hardship on the poor than on the rich (by way of taxes) ... I'm not sure what to say to that.  Your position as I understand it so far sounds an awful lot like, "Everyone needs to do their fair share, only the poor guy's fair share is harder than the rich guy's fair share."  I suppose you have a different concept of "fair".  Fair enough. 

Sorry, having more money makes life less hard. I don't think I want to live in a world where that's not true. If it was easy to be poor, why would anyone put forth the effort not to be?

Without the effort, what would the world be like?

Basically, you want the world to be a nice place, and it's not.



Taxes are voluntary



Repent or be destroyed

mrstickball said:
I find it ironic that MontanaHatchet says that Slimebeast is selfish when he's telling us that he can't provide for his relatives due to high taxation.

I really don't see how you, Montana, or anyone, could think that wanting to help relatives is a selfish thing, and shame on you, Montana, for saying that.

I don't like it because it's a similar attitude I've seem from Mafoo. That is, that someone's time holds some kind of great importance. If time was of great importance, none of us would ever play videogames. In fact, we'd spend every waking hour working and we wouldn't have much of a need for anything else than a bed to sleep in.

And shame on you for a lot of the things you've said or done on the forum. I won't name them, but you know what they are as much as anyone else.



 

 

MontanaHatchet said:
mrstickball said:
I find it ironic that MontanaHatchet says that Slimebeast is selfish when he's telling us that he can't provide for his relatives due to high taxation.

I really don't see how you, Montana, or anyone, could think that wanting to help relatives is a selfish thing, and shame on you, Montana, for saying that.

I don't like it because it's a similar attitude I've seem from Mafoo. That is, that someone's time holds some kind of great importance. If time was of great importance, none of us would ever play videogames. In fact, we'd spend every waking hour working and we wouldn't have much of a need for anything else than a bed to sleep in.

And shame on you for a lot of the things you've said or done on the forum. I won't name them, but you know what they are as much as anyone else.

It's not time.  It's the freedom to spend ones time how they would like.

When I "waste" my time playing videogames it's my choice and there is value in that.  I'm doing something I enjoy for leisure.

 

If you don't think is important and your own time is important.... think about how you feel when your waiting in line at a long line... and your stuck behind an old lady counting pennies, or writing a check, or something happens at a fast food place that takes longer then it should etc.


Sometimes you'll get absolutely pissed off about that stuff... and that's less then a half hour of your time.



Around the Network
Kasz216 said:
MontanaHatchet said:
mrstickball said:
I find it ironic that MontanaHatchet says that Slimebeast is selfish when he's telling us that he can't provide for his relatives due to high taxation.

I really don't see how you, Montana, or anyone, could think that wanting to help relatives is a selfish thing, and shame on you, Montana, for saying that.

I don't like it because it's a similar attitude I've seem from Mafoo. That is, that someone's time holds some kind of great importance. If time was of great importance, none of us would ever play videogames. In fact, we'd spend every waking hour working and we wouldn't have much of a need for anything else than a bed to sleep in.

And shame on you for a lot of the things you've said or done on the forum. I won't name them, but you know what they are as much as anyone else.

It's not time.  It's the freedom to spend ones time how they would like.

When I "waste" my time playing videogames it's my choice and there is value in that.  I'm doing something I enjoy for leisure.

 

If you don't think is important and your own time is important.... think about how you feel when your waiting in line at a long line... and your stuck behind an old lady counting pennies, or writing a check, or something happens at a fast food place that takes longer then it should etc.


Sometimes you'll get absolutely pissed off about that stuff... and that's less then a half hour of your time.

Yes, but the difference between leisure time and work time is important here. If someone takes up your free time, it's not a big deal. You weren't doing anything in that time that was all that important to your life (except possibly retaining your own sanity). If someone was taking time from you and you were going to spend that time working, that's another thing.

Point is, life is short, time isn't that important, and people should just shutup.



 

 

MontanaHatchet said:
Kasz216 said:
MontanaHatchet said:
mrstickball said:
I find it ironic that MontanaHatchet says that Slimebeast is selfish when he's telling us that he can't provide for his relatives due to high taxation.

I really don't see how you, Montana, or anyone, could think that wanting to help relatives is a selfish thing, and shame on you, Montana, for saying that.

I don't like it because it's a similar attitude I've seem from Mafoo. That is, that someone's time holds some kind of great importance. If time was of great importance, none of us would ever play videogames. In fact, we'd spend every waking hour working and we wouldn't have much of a need for anything else than a bed to sleep in.

And shame on you for a lot of the things you've said or done on the forum. I won't name them, but you know what they are as much as anyone else.

It's not time.  It's the freedom to spend ones time how they would like.

When I "waste" my time playing videogames it's my choice and there is value in that.  I'm doing something I enjoy for leisure.

 

If you don't think is important and your own time is important.... think about how you feel when your waiting in line at a long line... and your stuck behind an old lady counting pennies, or writing a check, or something happens at a fast food place that takes longer then it should etc.


Sometimes you'll get absolutely pissed off about that stuff... and that's less then a half hour of your time.

Yes, but the difference between leisure time and work time is important here. If someone takes up your free time, it's not a big deal. You weren't doing anything in that time that was all that important to your life (except possibly retaining your own sanity). If someone was taking time from you and you were going to spend that time working, that's another thing.

Point is, life is short, time isn't that important, and people should just shutup.

Isn't that exactly what's being taken?  Your time working that your paid for? 

Besides... i completely disagree.

Time is infinitly important.  Time is all our lives really are.  Our free time... unless you have an awesome job you enjoy (most don't) is infact all one has to define themselves and to lives ones life.  It's your time to live.  Your free time more or less is your life.]

If you have to work longer because more of your money is taken away... you lose free time that you use in defining your life.

If someone wants to define their life as "plays lots of videogames" is that really wasting ones life? 

Is that actually inherently worse then something else you could be doing with your free time?

 



Kasz216 said:
MontanaHatchet said:
Kasz216 said:
MontanaHatchet said:
mrstickball said:
I find it ironic that MontanaHatchet says that Slimebeast is selfish when he's telling us that he can't provide for his relatives due to high taxation.

I really don't see how you, Montana, or anyone, could think that wanting to help relatives is a selfish thing, and shame on you, Montana, for saying that.

I don't like it because it's a similar attitude I've seem from Mafoo. That is, that someone's time holds some kind of great importance. If time was of great importance, none of us would ever play videogames. In fact, we'd spend every waking hour working and we wouldn't have much of a need for anything else than a bed to sleep in.

And shame on you for a lot of the things you've said or done on the forum. I won't name them, but you know what they are as much as anyone else.

It's not time.  It's the freedom to spend ones time how they would like.

When I "waste" my time playing videogames it's my choice and there is value in that.  I'm doing something I enjoy for leisure.

 

If you don't think is important and your own time is important.... think about how you feel when your waiting in line at a long line... and your stuck behind an old lady counting pennies, or writing a check, or something happens at a fast food place that takes longer then it should etc.


Sometimes you'll get absolutely pissed off about that stuff... and that's less then a half hour of your time.

Yes, but the difference between leisure time and work time is important here. If someone takes up your free time, it's not a big deal. You weren't doing anything in that time that was all that important to your life (except possibly retaining your own sanity). If someone was taking time from you and you were going to spend that time working, that's another thing.

Point is, life is short, time isn't that important, and people should just shutup.

Isn't that exactly what's being taken?  Your time working that your paid for? 

Besides... i completely disagree.

Time is infinitly important.  Time is all our lives really are.  Our free time... unless you have an awesome job you enjoy (most don't) is infact all one has to define themselves and to lives ones life.  It's your time to live.  Your free time more or less is your life.]

If you have to work longer because more of your money is taken away... you lose free time that you use in defining your life.

If someone wants to define their life as "plays lots of videogames" is that really wasting ones life? 

Is that actually inherently worse then something else you could be doing with your free time?

 

For something that is infinitely important, it is squandered to an almost infinite degree. Humans have an infinitely important gift (life), but it won't even matter after you're dead. If you don't believe in an afterlife, there is no real value to your life. Once you're dead, nothing you did in your life will matter. At least not to you. You'll be a corpse in the ground. And if you do believe in an afterlife, you could spend your whole life praying in a chapel and get in all the same. So life is infinitely important while you're alive, but it only lasts so long.

I really don't want to get into a philosophical argument here, but one's life is ultimately unimportant to them in the end.



 

 

MontanaHatchet said:
Kasz216 said:
MontanaHatchet said:
Kasz216 said:
MontanaHatchet said:
mrstickball said:
I find it ironic that MontanaHatchet says that Slimebeast is selfish when he's telling us that he can't provide for his relatives due to high taxation.

I really don't see how you, Montana, or anyone, could think that wanting to help relatives is a selfish thing, and shame on you, Montana, for saying that.

I don't like it because it's a similar attitude I've seem from Mafoo. That is, that someone's time holds some kind of great importance. If time was of great importance, none of us would ever play videogames. In fact, we'd spend every waking hour working and we wouldn't have much of a need for anything else than a bed to sleep in.

And shame on you for a lot of the things you've said or done on the forum. I won't name them, but you know what they are as much as anyone else.

It's not time.  It's the freedom to spend ones time how they would like.

When I "waste" my time playing videogames it's my choice and there is value in that.  I'm doing something I enjoy for leisure.

 

If you don't think is important and your own time is important.... think about how you feel when your waiting in line at a long line... and your stuck behind an old lady counting pennies, or writing a check, or something happens at a fast food place that takes longer then it should etc.


Sometimes you'll get absolutely pissed off about that stuff... and that's less then a half hour of your time.

Yes, but the difference between leisure time and work time is important here. If someone takes up your free time, it's not a big deal. You weren't doing anything in that time that was all that important to your life (except possibly retaining your own sanity). If someone was taking time from you and you were going to spend that time working, that's another thing.

Point is, life is short, time isn't that important, and people should just shutup.

Isn't that exactly what's being taken?  Your time working that your paid for? 

Besides... i completely disagree.

Time is infinitly important.  Time is all our lives really are.  Our free time... unless you have an awesome job you enjoy (most don't) is infact all one has to define themselves and to lives ones life.  It's your time to live.  Your free time more or less is your life.]

If you have to work longer because more of your money is taken away... you lose free time that you use in defining your life.

If someone wants to define their life as "plays lots of videogames" is that really wasting ones life? 

Is that actually inherently worse then something else you could be doing with your free time?

 

For something that is infinitely important, it is squandered to an almost infinite degree. Humans have an infinitely important gift (life), but it won't even matter after you're dead. If you don't believe in an afterlife, there is no real value to your life. Once you're dead, nothing you did in your life will matter. At least not to you. You'll be a corpse in the ground. And if you do believe in an afterlife, you could spend your whole life praying in a chapel and get in all the same. So life is infinitely important while you're alive, but it only lasts so long.

I really don't want to get into a philosophical argument here, but one's life is ultimately unimportant to them in the end.

1) For atheists that only applies if you are a Nihilist.  Which most atheists aren't.  For most living your life is important in general. 

2) For people with religion... life shapes you.  If it wasn't for life... and everyone was raised and born instantly in the afterlife, no personalities would evolve because everyone would live the same.  What one does in their life shapes who they will be in their afterlife... and in some cases where they will go. (And in others, what life they will live again)

3) There is no such thing as wasting your life.

4) The people being taxed are alive while they're being taxed.



Every time I see this discussion I am reminded of a childrens story that I swear most people must not have been told growing up. Its called "The Little Red Hen" and it tells the story of a hen who (even though she constantly asks for help) ends up putting in all the work to bake a loaf of bread, and then all the people she asked for help expect to share the bread when she has completed ... The reason I think it is such a appropriate story is that most high income earners put in a lot of effort to develop valueable skills, and/or took on a lot of risk to build a business from the ground up, and none of these people who expect a share of their income were willing to help them.

Certainly, there are exceptions, but a large portion of the low income earners represent a group of people who choose to have fun and party when they were young; and why should they be rewarded for being so self centered and short sighted when, like many people have before them, they could have put in the effort to make their lives so much better.