I don't see you owning a PS3.

+ SMG
- Gears of War

+ MGS4
- Halo3

Well since Halo 3 is fucked i'll start to vote for the second best game this generation:

+ Mass Effect
- F.E.A.R.

X-Men Origins Wolverine?

Hey MGS4 got eliminated...I thought it looked fishy that it was at 24 with all the negative votes it was getting.

And to be fair i looked at my fav game, Halo 3 and it got eliminated too.  

+ Call Of Duty 4
- Valkyria Chronicles

@ dtewi: why do we need to own the console to have played the games?

+ LoZ: twilight princess
- Okami

I was gonna recount everything, but got tired of it after i got to Bioshock.

BTW Assassins Creed got eliminated too.

Megaman I would recomend you recount everything, cause alot of stuff is way off...

It is that is unlikely to have played any game and judge it throughly if you don't own the console unless it was borrowed for a few weeks.