By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Remedy:'Alan Wake is Xbox 360 exclusive' (PC version shelved indefinitely)

richardhutnik said:
tronied said:

I love this... ps3 and PC fans have been saying for ages that the 360 has no real exclusives as everything is coming out on PC too. Then, as soon as one is made a 360 exclusive, everyone starts complaining about how Microsoft is ignoring their other platform - seriously, they can't win. As has been said, most 360 console exclusives are going to the Windows platform anyway, so I personally don't see what the problem is if they want to make an exclusive out of the game.

You never know, if sales are good on the 360 it will probably be ported to the PC anyway as its in Microsoft's best interest to do so. They, more than anyone don't want to see windows as a gaming platform die as its one of the reasons that Windows as an OS stands out above the rest.

PS3 and PC fans want Microsoft to fail in the console business, so that it both forces Microsoft's development to stay on the PC only, and forces console owners to ONLY buy a Sony console, so third-party will not divide their efforts elsewhere, and the PS3 owners can feel like they are top dog.  That is what is going on here.  Besides, this move also undermines the Playstation fanboy charge that the ALL games on the 360 are also on the PS3, so why bother with an XBox console? 

I will lead my people to deliverance. So one day the PSFA or Playstation Fan Alliance will bring fanboys like you to justice!



Tease.

Around the Network

It is understandable the PC version of the game may be canceled due to widespread PC game piracy which severely reduces PC game sales.



I wasn't planning on buying this, but it's bull that they'd announce a PC version, demo the game on PC specifically to show off DX10 capabilities as a means of selling Vista, and then cancel the PC version. =/

I'm not much of horror fan anyway, though. My next big PC release will be Supreme Commander 2. I'm upgrading my PC in October just for this game. :D

Kinda funny that the best game Square Enix will ever publish is an RTS. >_>



shio said:
tyig said:

http://cache.gawker.com/assets/images/9/2009/02/340x_acticonsoles.jpg

 

Come on, the worst console for activision(ps3) is 2.5 times the revenue of the PC nom-mmorpg games, if it's not mmorpg it really is DEAD.No point putting this game on pc

I'm pretty sure any sales from WoW on retail is included on "MMORPG section", and any Digital sale from a PC game is included on "Distribution section" (which is what EA does too). so this shows nothing of how it really is.

 

"Distribution" is listed in that same table farther down.  Combined distribution and non-MMORPG PC revenue are still less than a third of their total revenue from console games.  That table is from their official, audited financial statements so don't even try to say they only represent part of the world market.  That table shows the complete picture from Activision_Blizzard's point of view.

 

@topic:  I was planning on buying the 360 version anyway so this doesn't really affect me, but I can understand the people who were planning on buying it on PC being upset.  Only those who would have paid for it though, I have no sympathy for the would-be pirates.



Garnett said:

MS must be focusing on the Xbox 360..

 

OMG imagen...Alan Wake with Natal! You have to move around like a real person and use a fake flashlight :D


D00d...your making me drool!!

 

MS Innovation >>> Ninty Innovation!



Around the Network
PS3beats360 said:
It is understandable the PC version of the game may be canceled due to widespread PC game piracy which severely reduces PC game sales.

True,the Pc porting cost will be higher than the profit,so it was a good move. Pc piracy is another reason.

But the true reason is that MS needs a true 360 exclusive. With minimum costs,it has one. What more could they want?

If they do release it on Pc,the high system demands and piracy will kill the profit of the port and everyone will say,as they always do, "it`s on Pc also,so it`s not exclusive"...then comes the talk "it`s console exclusive because the ps3 doesn`t get it and Pc is not a console,etc etc..."

Alan Wake is a 360 exclusive sponsored and published by MS...the end.



richardhutnik said:
Steroid said:
PC gaming is dead confirmed. Who woulda thunk MS would be the ones to do it though?

Not dead, but Microsoft closing down PC development studios should be a tip-off to something going on regarding them and PC gaming.

Yes, they are shifting all their support to the Xbox, where it makes them the most money (though they have still lost money with the xbox 360)

greenmedic88 said:
richardhutnik said:
shio said:
yo_john117 said:
Steroid said:
PC gaming is dead confirmed. Who woulda thunk MS would be the ones to do it though?

Maybe they aren't making much money off of PC gaming anymore. Either way its good that they are doing that.  

PC gaming can go to hell for all i care, way to much hassle to make it even remotly worth it.

PC gaming has been growing really fast, with over 300 millions online PC gamers today. PC gaming is stronger than ever, and many experts/analysts think PC gaming will kill Console gaming, especially with the coming of Onlive and Gaikai.

MANY?  I am sorry, believing you cloned one or two 100 million times, doesn't make that MANY (if you did do it, it would be the same voice over and over).  I saw ONE article on here regarding that on here in the MONTHS I have been reading.  But I guess you assumed that ONE article was over a dozen, by a bunch of pro-PC Michael Pachters type analysts.

PC gaming is either Downloads or pirates, with the retail area shrinking down to the size of what Macs used to hold.

And good luck waiting on OnLive, that didn't even bother showing up at E3.  Nice to know you can play Crysis on a lousy laptop, and play 2008 videogame releases that are then released on the PC this year, and believe they are 2009 PC game releases, because they were released on the PC this year.

People do seem to be pulling numbers out of assumptions at this point.

But it's pretty hard to deny that retail PC gaming is on the decline (even if just off anecdotal observations of shrinking retail space for games). More PC gamers are buying their games through DD services. And unfortunately, even more are simply stealing their games online for free.

I'm not even sure why anyone is touting Onlive as the future of PC gaming at this point, even if it does work EXACTLY as advertised on the weakest Atom powered netbook in existence as well as 10 year old PCs held together with bubble gum and duct tape. Onlive has a huge amount of logistical issues to address before their business model is viable. No one should count on it "replacing consoles."

But if they get everything up and running and are able to convince all the major software publishers to partner up, it's not going to be limited to old games obviously. Any new PC release should be made shortly avalable for play, no different than Steam or other DD services.

Onlive already has the support of EA and Blizzard Activision and a few others, so they only need to make Onlive work properly.

richardhutnik said:
JaggedSac said:
Wow, he actually came back and said CoD4 sold more on PC.

Also, I love how he has zero items to back up his claims. Wow. I am flabbergasted.

He also mentioned a graph produced by a site that has no direct line to Live data. They are basing there claims on members of a site. Very inaccurate.

shio comes on a videogame fan forum (mostly console owners) and needs to feel ballsy about the PC's standings for gaming, so anything that undermines this would cause shio's world to fall apart.  He can't bear to think that consoles still remain relevant, and for a multitude of reasons, more developers would rather create games for consoles than the PC.

Huh? I have nothing against consoles except the fact that it's awful to play a FPS with a gamepad, and a gamepad gives nowhere near the possibilities a Keyboard+Mouse does in terms of gameplay. And actually there are more developers working on PC games than in all consoles combined.

richardhutnik said:
shio said:
 

 

They haven't. Activision itself said that the numbers they reported were only from 5/6 markets, most of them console-centric. They didn't include numbers from portugal, sweden, norway, finland, iceland, russia, ukraine, poland, and other dozens of countries, and no doubt they didn't even mention the digital sales.

for example, when they reported COD4 sold 7 millions it only encompassed North America, UK, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and Benelux. Only France, Germany and Benelux are PC-centric, but they can't even compare to North-America (USA+Canada), UK, Italy and Spain. This means they left out dozens of PC-centric countries and digital sales.

So the electronic gaming industry is bigger in these other PC-centric countries by a factor of what?  Can you list that number?  Please state how much more video/computer games sell in Eastern Europe and Asian then the markets mentioned.  Can you even do this?  Or, do you like to lurk behind fog, with the belief in this fog is a monster that will devower all the console peons that refuse to bow to the glory of your PC master race.  And if these markets are so huge, as you hint at, and digital downloads as large as you are making them out to be, why doesn't Acitivision list them?  Are they hiding these revenues offshore in accounts, to avoid paying taxes?  Isn't there laws against this, and there could be a class-action lawsuit by shareholders for underreporting revenue?  Or, is it that the money from digital downloads and unreported countries are unknown by Activision, and it shows up in unmarked bills in their corporate headquarters when they aren't looking?  In other words, they accounting flat out SUCKS that they are unable to track revenue.  Or is it that you count PIRATING of games as actual digital distribution of games?

And how much bigger is digital downloads over the entire videogame industry?  You make it out like Steam is bigger than World of Warcraft. 

Eastern european and asian markets are the fastest growing markets in the videogame industry. Sure, they're not big, but in them PC gaming is so big and because they are becoming more relevant it is only a good thing for PC gaming. As for China, it increased 75% last year, and very soon it will become bigger than the Japanese market.

Activision didn't list those countries because they took from NPD Group, Chart Track, and GfK Group, and those three don't track the eastern european markets, nor asian markets.

PS3beats360 said:
It is understandable the PC version of the game may be canceled due to widespread PC game piracy which severely reduces PC game sales.

Was that the reason they said they cancelled Alan Wake for PC? Infact, they blamed Microsoft, not piracy.

Stan85 said:
PS3beats360 said:
It is understandable the PC version of the game may be canceled due to widespread PC game piracy which severely reduces PC game sales.

True,the Pc porting cost will be higher than the profit,so it was a good move. Pc piracy is another reason.

But the true reason is that MS needs a true 360 exclusive. With minimum costs,it has one. What more could they want?

If they do release it on Pc,the high system demands and piracy will kill the profit of the port and everyone will say,as they always do, "it`s on Pc also,so it`s not exclusive"...then comes the talk "it`s console exclusive because the ps3 doesn`t get it and Pc is not a console,etc etc..."

Alan Wake is a 360 exclusive sponsored and published by MS...the end.

The game was being developed on PC, not Xbox 360. Remedy PR specifically blamed the publisher(which is Microsoft) for denying the release of the PC version, not piracy.

This piracy arugment is blown out of proportion. Piracy is bad but when even small developers can make million sellers on PC without any advertisement, when there are more developers on PC than ever, more PC games than ever and dozens of niche markets flourish on PC...

 

 

 

 

 

 



Delivering platform is a publisher's choice, Shio.

You can't blame Microsoft for looking after their own interests.

Otherwise you better be bitching about every single game not released on a PC.





Current-gen game collection uploaded on the profile, full of win and good games; also most of my PC games. Lucasfilm Games/LucasArts 1982-2008 (Requiescat In Pace).

Bitmap Frogs said:
Delivering platform is a publisher's choice, Shio.

You can't blame Microsoft for looking after their own interests.

Otherwise you better be bitching about every single game not released on a PC.

Yes, companies do what they must for profit, but Microsoft had previously commited itself to the release of Alan Wake on the PC, a game that was first and foremost and PC game, that many PC fans had longed for. It's not legally wrong what they did, but I'd say it's ethically wrong. I do not believe they should give some sort of compensation to the PC platform or anything, the biggest one to blame is Remedy for giving Microsoft power to do such a thing.

Anyway, I brought this up more to say the real reason Alan Wake isn't coming to PC, since so many people in this thread erroneously believe that Alan Wake is not coming to PC because of piracy.



Glad this happened, has some real exclusives now, I hope MS drops all support for PC gaming. The only thing PC gaming is good for is RTS's and MMO's.