By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Forza Vs GT - one thing is abundantly clear...

kn said:
Dno said:

Your opinion not mine or many others.... i love both and i own both but your comparing GT5 PRO with a full retail forza 2....

Why dont we all just stop this and when both FULL games drop we can start it up again.... if i see another thread about which is better i will burn it......

Both games are good thats that....

"I realize that GT5:P is just a prologue so it isn't fair to compare all the extra stuff in Forza 2 like purchasing performance parts, painting, auctions, online features, and so on so I'll just leave it at that."

I clearly pointed that out, I thought, and was just speaking of simulation and graphics -- those areas where everyone likes to say one kills the other.  They don't.  Both are spectacular in those regards.

I'm sick of the threads as well, but my point is that most of the threads are from assholes that don't have a clue what they are comparing.

like i said in my first post its your opinion.. i think its a fact that PD used more polygons on GT5 pro cars then forza 2... if you had compared forza 3 then id say you are prolly right but forza 2 looks like crap right now... i own both you can look at my gamer tag for proof.

 

Forza2 single handedly got me into the sim racing genre. its pretty clear that i love sony but i was never a fan of their GT series into forza 2 dropped. AFter playing forza 2 i loked at one trailer of GT5 and i was floored. So i played both JUST as much (mab a litle less) then you have and all i have to say is both are good but after playing GT5 Pro im now HOOKED onthe GT series.. I have not seen forza 3 gamplay yet but if you compare forza 2 and GT5 Pros graphics GT wins by far...



Around the Network
Dno said:
kn said:
Dno said:

Your opinion not mine or many others.... i love both and i own both but your comparing GT5 PRO with a full retail forza 2....

Why dont we all just stop this and when both FULL games drop we can start it up again.... if i see another thread about which is better i will burn it......

Both games are good thats that....

"I realize that GT5:P is just a prologue so it isn't fair to compare all the extra stuff in Forza 2 like purchasing performance parts, painting, auctions, online features, and so on so I'll just leave it at that."

I clearly pointed that out, I thought, and was just speaking of simulation and graphics -- those areas where everyone likes to say one kills the other.  They don't.  Both are spectacular in those regards.

I'm sick of the threads as well, but my point is that most of the threads are from assholes that don't have a clue what they are comparing.

like i said in my first post its your opinion.. i think its a fact that PD used more polygons on GT5 pro cars then forza 2... if you had compared forza 3 then id say you are prolly right but forza 2 looks like crap right now... i own both you can look at my gamer tag for proof.

 

Forza2 single handedly got me into the sim racing genre. its pretty clear that i love sony but i was never a fan of their GT series into forza 2 dropped. AFter playing forza 2 i loked at one trailer of GT5 and i was floored. So i played both JUST as much (mab a litle less) then you have and all i have to say is both are good but after playing GT5 Pro im now HOOKED onthe GT series.. I have not seen forza 3 gamplay yet but if you compare forza 2 and GT5 Pros graphics GT wins by far...

By far?  GT5:5 car models are definitely better but trackside detail is quite poor.  If you look at the reflections from the environment on the hood of the cars in GT5:P, you can see that they are VERY low resolution.  Outside of the car models themselves, there isn't anything special about GT5:P's graphics.

Forza does NOT look like crap.  Are you playing on a high-def TV?  Perhaps there is something I'm missing because the car models are very next-gen in Forza 2 -- very, very far from crap.  As good as GT5:P?  Certainly not but let's be honest here...  It's not like PS2 vs. PS3 graphics, now is it?



I hate trolls.

Systems I currently own:  360, PS3, Wii, DS Lite (2)
Systems I've owned: PS2, PS1, Dreamcast, Saturn, 3DO, Genesis, Gamecube, N64, SNES, NES, GBA, GB, C64, Amiga, Atari 2600 and 5200, Sega Game Gear, Vectrex, Intellivision, Pong.  Yes, Pong.

in the graphics department gt5p beats F2, that is a fact.



kn said:
Dno said:
kn said:
Dno said:

Your opinion not mine or many others.... i love both and i own both but your comparing GT5 PRO with a full retail forza 2....

Why dont we all just stop this and when both FULL games drop we can start it up again.... if i see another thread about which is better i will burn it......

Both games are good thats that....

"I realize that GT5:P is just a prologue so it isn't fair to compare all the extra stuff in Forza 2 like purchasing performance parts, painting, auctions, online features, and so on so I'll just leave it at that."

I clearly pointed that out, I thought, and was just speaking of simulation and graphics -- those areas where everyone likes to say one kills the other.  They don't.  Both are spectacular in those regards.

I'm sick of the threads as well, but my point is that most of the threads are from assholes that don't have a clue what they are comparing.

like i said in my first post its your opinion.. i think its a fact that PD used more polygons on GT5 pro cars then forza 2... if you had compared forza 3 then id say you are prolly right but forza 2 looks like crap right now... i own both you can look at my gamer tag for proof.

 

Forza2 single handedly got me into the sim racing genre. its pretty clear that i love sony but i was never a fan of their GT series into forza 2 dropped. AFter playing forza 2 i loked at one trailer of GT5 and i was floored. So i played both JUST as much (mab a litle less) then you have and all i have to say is both are good but after playing GT5 Pro im now HOOKED onthe GT series.. I have not seen forza 3 gamplay yet but if you compare forza 2 and GT5 Pros graphics GT wins by far...

By far?  GT5:5 car models are definitely better but trackside detail is quite poor.  If you look at the reflections from the environment on the hood of the cars in GT5:P, you can see that they are VERY low resolution.  Outside of the car models themselves, there isn't anything special about GT5:P's graphics.

Forza does NOT look like crap.  Are you playing on a high-def TV?  Perhaps there is something I'm missing because the car models are very next-gen in Forza 2 -- very, very far from crap.  As good as GT5:P?  Certainly not but let's be honest here...  It's not like PS2 vs. PS3 graphics, now is it?

i have a 1080p sony XBR 40 inch complete with DTS surrond sound.. my setup is great.

ALL i said is forza 2 a game thats more then 2 years old looks like crap to todays standards... motorstorm, GT5 pro, fuel, dirt, killzone 2 uncharted 2 are all games that prove this.. i dont think you have played forza 2 lately lol..

 

JUST because I say this does NOT mean i dont like it.. i love it but its BUT is has been out done over the years.... now forza 3 looks wonderful and proves that they can get MUCH more out of their engine on the xbox.



Noticable differences between the two are obvious, GT5:P cars look good, but when you are racing, the game can slow down to a crawl when more than 4 cars show up on screen. This does not happen in Forza 2. The track environments for GT5P are sub par, and when looking through the rear view mirror, most objects don't show up at all (except the cars and the track).

The one problem I have with GT5P is the time trials. It should be one car for a specific track, not whoever has the fastest car.



                                   

Around the Network
masterb8tr said:
in the graphics department gt5p beats F2, that is a fact.

This..

i understand forza 3 but part 2???? im sorry i just dont see it.



here is your answer to GT5p vs Forza2 thing:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7M5gQIKkYYA
to people who still argue that GT5p is a demo so it doesn't count lets do:
Race Pro vs Gt5p - same price, but than again Race Pro would blown GT completely in every category outside graphics(it have more simillar content and gameplay than Forza so it's a fair comparison).



SlumsofOhio said:

Noticable differences between the two are obvious, GT5:P cars look good, but when you are racing, the game can slow down to a crawl when more than 4 cars show up on screen. This does not happen in Forza 2. The track environments for GT5P are sub par, and when looking through the rear view mirror, most objects don't show up at all (except the cars and the track).

The one problem I have with GT5P is the time trials. It should be one car for a specific track, not whoever has the fastest car.

I've not noticed the slowdown in GT5:P.  I'll have to go drive in a crowd more.  The game is too easy IMO and shortly after start, I'm out in front and don't have the crowds.



I hate trolls.

Systems I currently own:  360, PS3, Wii, DS Lite (2)
Systems I've owned: PS2, PS1, Dreamcast, Saturn, 3DO, Genesis, Gamecube, N64, SNES, NES, GBA, GB, C64, Amiga, Atari 2600 and 5200, Sega Game Gear, Vectrex, Intellivision, Pong.  Yes, Pong.

"If you are a Sony fanboy and think that GT5:P somehow smokes Forza 2, move along. Go to the bank, take out a loan, and buy a clue. The Forza 2 demo is good. The game is GREAT. Better than GT5:P when all things are considered. When the FULL GT5 comes out, there is no doubt it will be an amazing game. But then so will Forza 3 so, again, just leave it alone."

Since when is your opinion fact?



kn said:
SlumsofOhio said:

Noticable differences between the two are obvious, GT5:P cars look good, but when you are racing, the game can slow down to a crawl when more than 4 cars show up on screen. This does not happen in Forza 2. The track environments for GT5P are sub par, and when looking through the rear view mirror, most objects don't show up at all (except the cars and the track).

The one problem I have with GT5P is the time trials. It should be one car for a specific track, not whoever has the fastest car.

I've not noticed the slowdown in GT5:P.  I'll have to go drive in a crowd more.  The game is too easy IMO and shortly after start, I'm out in front and don't have the crowds.

It doesn't happen often at Daytona because of the space each car has, but on the Suzuka circuit, it shows up on the first turn at the start of the race. It can happen at Fuji Speedway too.