Last month a number of 360 people were slamming Edge for a low review of BioShock...

 This month they gave even lower reviews of some of the most hyped titles.

http://www.n4g.com/News-70619.aspx

I really don't understand it myself....

3/10 ;p

holy crap, metroid prime 7? wtf?

Wow, they went hard on some of these games, and quite lenient on others

yes and the Officical Xbox Mag UK put 10/10 for PGR4

who saied it is baised ?

and 10/10 for Halo3 : yes so great game,

you just have to put away 1.5 to Halo3 and PGR4

and add 2 to Lair ... you will get the real score !

Blah - EDGE. Lost respect for those guys years ago.

From what I have read, Halo3 has enough flaws to definitely not be a 10 (its a 9).

And giving Metroid a 7... no comment. 

disappointing scores for Eternal Sonata and Singstar at 7 and 8 respectively. Fantastic effort for PGR4 and Halo 3. Halo deserves it, i'll wait and see on PGR. Wow, i mean we knew Lair was bad, but 3? Harsh? lol, no.

EDGE are really harsh scorers; But seeing Metroid Prime 3 = Stranglehold doesn't seem right at all.

Metroid gets put down for not being competitive graphics-wise with 360 as well as being a part of a trilogy

Halo doesn't move for having inferior fps controls to Wii as well as being part of a trilogy..

I just don't think there is much consistency with the thought processes of a lot of reviewers (i'm not talking about EGM, since all we have is a score without reasoning atm)

No one complains about Pesona 3 scoring a 7???