By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Cage: Heavy Rain not possible on Xbox 360

nightsurge on 15 May 2009
Vetteman94 said:
CGI-Quality said:
Aren't you guys being a tad harsh to nightsurge? Afterall, he did say it was his opinion, he didn't post in absolutes. Furthermore, maybe he does favor the 360, but he's just giving his opinion. Let's not lynch him for it fellas...

I normally would but I dont recall ever seeing him say one positive thing towards the PS3 or any of its games.   Maybe he has and I never saw them, but I doubt it. 

 

Have you said positive things about the 360 or any of its games?  Just curious because I've never seen you do so.

And yes I have said many nice things about Killzone 2 when I played it, and Resistance 2 when I played that.  The rest of my supposed "negativity" towards PS3 is all based on personal experiences, which you must realize that not everyone's experiences are the same and some people can have negative experiences with the PS3 and positive ones with the 360 (and vice versa).

 



Around the Network
TheTruthProphet on 15 May 2009

more LIES and PROPAGANDA from people on SONY'S PAYROLL.

WHAT employee is going to say good things about a competitor?

ps3 and xbox 360 are the same. ps3 is NOT more powerful....it has been proven by David Shippy (Head engineer of the cell and xenon processor at ibm)

Heavy Rain won't sell more than 750k lifetime



Vetteman94 on 15 May 2009
Shadowblind said:
Vetteman94 said:
nightsurge said:
Vetteman94 said:
nightsurge said:
Vetteman94 said:
waron said:
Vetteman94 said:
waron said:
not again "sony payed us to make ps3 exclusive so we say it's not possible on a 360 despite the fact that it looks worse, IMO, than some of 3rd party multiplatform games on xbox 360" crap.

Fixed for you

Also I dont remember Sony paying for anything with this game, if I am not mistaken Quantic Dream can take this game anywhere they want to. I am sure CGI has the correct answer on this.

 

*looks at NFS: Shift gameplay* nah multiplatform games DO look better than exclusive ones

*Looks at Gran Turismo 5 gameplay*   laughs at your comment,  exclusive games are always better

 

I just looked at gameplay footage from both and NFS looked better to me.  NFS video had lots more stuff on the scene (more buildings, cars, better interior and exterior details) than the GT5 video (more of a closed pro-race track) and it still looked better to me =/

 

Of course it did, to you it would. 

 

Because my eyes are broken?  I made an honest judgement.  I don't want either game so there is no reason for me to favor either.  I just wanted to check what you both were arguing about and from the vids I saw on YouTube HD and G4 the NFS ones looked better.... Sorry if that somehow affects you?

Oh it wont effect me since I am getting both.  But not wanting either game has as much effect on your bias as saying "I own all 3 consoles".   You saw the vids on youtube and G4, knowing one was a PS3 exclusive and the other a PC, 360 & PS3 multiplat and made your desicion that way.  

 


So...he's not aloud to think one game looks better then the other? Not everyone who thinks GT5 looks worse then a multiplat game hates the PS3.

I don't know whether or not hes bias, but your showing your bias loud and proud...

I cant be biased,  I own a PS3 and a 360

 



nightsurge on 15 May 2009
hatmoza 2.0 said:
CGI-Quality said:
Aren't you guys being a tad harsh to nightsurge? Afterall, he did say it was his opinion, he didn't post in absolutes. Furthermore, maybe he does favor the 360, but he's just giving his opinion. Let's not lynch him for it fellas...

....Huh!? *hides pitchfork behind back*

 

*sneaks up behind hatmoza and tickles him until he wets himself*

 



Vetteman94 on 15 May 2009
nightsurge said:
Vetteman94 said:
CGI-Quality said:
Aren't you guys being a tad harsh to nightsurge? Afterall, he did say it was his opinion, he didn't post in absolutes. Furthermore, maybe he does favor the 360, but he's just giving his opinion. Let's not lynch him for it fellas...

I normally would but I dont recall ever seeing him say one positive thing towards the PS3 or any of its games.   Maybe he has and I never saw them, but I doubt it. 

 

Have you said positive things about the 360 or any of its games?  Just curious because I've never seen you do so.

And yes I have said many nice things about Killzone 2 when I played it, and Resistance 2 when I played that.  The rest of my supposed "negativity" towards PS3 is all based on personal experiences, which you must realize that not everyone's experiences are the same and some people can have negative experiences with the PS3 and positive ones with the 360 (and vice versa).

 

Yes I have plenty of times, I do own one, and quite a few games.   

As for the other comments, I am sorry I jumped on your case so quickly, I understand personal experiences can change the way you feel about things.

 



Around the Network
nightsurge on 15 May 2009
Vetteman94 said:
Shadowblind said:
Vetteman94 said:
nightsurge said:
Vetteman94 said:
nightsurge said:
Vetteman94 said:
waron said:
Vetteman94 said:
waron said:
not again "sony payed us to make ps3 exclusive so we say it's not possible on a 360 despite the fact that it looks worse, IMO, than some of 3rd party multiplatform games on xbox 360" crap.

Fixed for you

Also I dont remember Sony paying for anything with this game, if I am not mistaken Quantic Dream can take this game anywhere they want to. I am sure CGI has the correct answer on this.

 

*looks at NFS: Shift gameplay* nah multiplatform games DO look better than exclusive ones

*Looks at Gran Turismo 5 gameplay*   laughs at your comment,  exclusive games are always better

 

I just looked at gameplay footage from both and NFS looked better to me.  NFS video had lots more stuff on the scene (more buildings, cars, better interior and exterior details) than the GT5 video (more of a closed pro-race track) and it still looked better to me =/

 

Of course it did, to you it would. 

 

Because my eyes are broken?  I made an honest judgement.  I don't want either game so there is no reason for me to favor either.  I just wanted to check what you both were arguing about and from the vids I saw on YouTube HD and G4 the NFS ones looked better.... Sorry if that somehow affects you?

Oh it wont effect me since I am getting both.  But not wanting either game has as much effect on your bias as saying "I own all 3 consoles".   You saw the vids on youtube and G4, knowing one was a PS3 exclusive and the other a PC, 360 & PS3 multiplat and made your desicion that way.  

 


So...he's not aloud to think one game looks better then the other? Not everyone who thinks GT5 looks worse then a multiplat game hates the PS3.

I don't know whether or not hes bias, but your showing your bias loud and proud...

I cant be biased,  I own a PS3 and a 360

 

And I must be biased because I don't own a PS3. Retracted after Vetteman's post.  Thank you

Also, thank you CGI.  Glad I can always count on you, bro.  Oh and you still have not added me to LIVE

 



ocnkng on 15 May 2009
nightsurge said:
ocnkng said:
nightsurge said:
ocnkng said:
nightsurge said:
Vetteman94 said:
nightsurge said:
Vetteman94 said:
waron said:
Vetteman94 said:

 

 

 

 

So you basically passed judgement on two games that you didn't even play.

Something is broken somewhere.

 

Did I say that one sucked? No.  I was judging on their graphics.  It isn't even a final judgement or anything, I was simply comparing what these two people were and made my own honest decision.

Is there anything else you need me to clarify?

Well basically you passed judgement on the graphics of two games that have not yet released and that you have seen youtube demos of.

You do not have enough evidence to say which one is better. Yet you did.

But then its allright coz its your opinion, something you seem to have made up even b4 you saw the videos.

So its k and really no need to clarify at all.

 

Hey genious, maybe you should understand something before trying to look smart.  They were the ones passing judgement based on gameplay videos.  I merely repeated their procedure to give another take on their topic.  So it is OK for Vetteman to make a judgement based on videos and not me?  Also, I had no opinion before watching the videos, that is why I was surpised by NFS's detail in the interior and of the actual track elements and scenery.  I'm sorry that you feel I have to be biased in order to think something looks better than GT5.

Apparently I did have to clarify for you.

 

 

So its ok if someone else is doing it too. Ya and it was Waron who started comparing.

Ok as I said you got every right to say whatever you feel. I was just pointing out something that made no sense.

Anyway thats that. I am off this conversation.



 

It is better to die on one's feet

then live on one's knees

TheTruthProphet on 15 May 2009
CGI-Quality said:
TheTruthProphet said:
more LIES and PROPAGANDA from people on SONY'S PAYROLL.

WHAT employee is going to say good things about a competitor?

ps3 and xbox 360 are the same. ps3 is NOT more powerful....it has been proven by David Shippy (Head engineer of the cell and xenon processor at ibm)

Heavy Rain won't sell more than 750k lifetime

Do you ever post anything positive, I mean really? I see you're a sales = quality person. Well, fortunately, it doesn't work that way

 

 Like I said i the other room -

Xbox 360 has 139 games rated above 80 on metacritic.  Sony only has 93

XBOX 360 has GREATER QUALITY & GREATER QUANTITY!!!



nightsurge on 15 May 2009

Yeah and I didn't mean to downplay Heavy Rain by saying it wouldn't get past 1 million LT sales. I am sure the game itself will be awesome I just don't think the genre is as popular as forums make it sound, and tying it to just one console instead of being multiplat like Indigo Prophecy may hurt its sales.



Vetteman94 on 15 May 2009
nightsurge said:
Yeah and I didn't mean to downplay Heavy Rain by saying it wouldn't get past 1 million LT sales. I am sure the game itself will be awesome I just don't think the genre is as popular as forums make it sound, and tying it to just one console instead of being multiplat like Indigo Prophecy may hurt its sales.

 

 Well it probably wont, it is a very niche game.   I am just hoping that with the way Sony themselves keep talking about it, maybe they will advertise the game some.  And that could go along way in helping sales.  And if that doesnt work I'll buy 2 copies