I can think 5.

Almoast All magazines/sites I read gave it Game of the year award.

1 gave Mgs 4.

Too many.

LBP:

its a shame many people on this site veiw bad sales = bad game. While it certainly hasn't been selling in the amounts people anticipated, it is a game many people should pick up. Think about it....that many game of the year picks means something. I usually prefer editor picks cause they play everything pretty much. If you have a people choice poll on games, what ends up happening is a popularity contest on only those who play in minor amounts see the big name titles they're familiar with and choose that.

Its just Ps3 owners.Because game cost 70€,people watch what they buy.We have had many hardcore games,and Ps3 users are most of "hardcore" people.
In time it will sell.