EDIT: This should be right (even though it looks crappy). Three people all posted at the same time, so things got messed up.



14 - Mario (Platformers)

13 - Ace Attorney
13 - Half-Life
13 - Kirby

13 - Legend of Zelda, The
13 - Mega Man
13 - Metroid
13 - Star Fox
13 - Diablo

12 - Dragon Quest
12 - Paper Mario
12 - Pikmin
12 - Ratchet and Clank
12 - Resident Evil

11 - Castlevania
11 - Fire Emblem
11 - Kingdom Hearts
11 - Mario Kart
11 - Super Smash Bros.
11 - Tales

10 - Command and Conquer
10 - Tetris
10 - Bomberman
10 - Donkey Kong
10 - Monster Hunter
10 - Pokemon

10 - Tomb Raider

9 - Age of Empires
9 - Animal Crossing
9 - Banjo Kazooie
9 - Final Fantasy
9 - Guitar Hero
9 - SimCity

9 - Sonic the Hedgehog

8 - Call of Duty
8 - Mario (Sports)
8 - Phantasy Star
8 - Prince of Persia
8 - WarCraft
8 - Mortal Kombat

7 - StarCraft
7 - Doctor Mario
7 - Dynasty Warriors
7 - Jak and Daxter
7 - Star Wars

6 - Brain Age
6 - Devil May Cry
6 - Doom
6 - Fallout
6 - Rayman
6 - Resistance
6 - Rock Band

5 - Lego
5 - Lemmings

4 - James Bond
4 - SOCOM
4 - Soul Calibur
4 - Wii

2 - Tom Clancy

2 - Street Fighter



ELIMINATED 1 - Yu-Gi-Oh!, 2 - Nickelodeon, 3 - WWE SmackDown, 4 - Harry Potter, 5 - Madden NFL, 6 - Grand Theft Auto, 7 - Simple, 8 - Dragonball Z, 9 - FIFA, 10 - Winning Eleven (PES), 11 - Marvel, 12 - Tony Hawk, 13 - Alone in the Dark, 14 - Frogger, 15 - Spyro, 16 - Tekken, 17 - Dance Dance Revolution, 18 - Need for Speed, 19 - Halo, 20 - Mario Party, 21 - The Sims, 22 - Gran Turismo, 23 - Pixar, 24 - Bejeweled, 25 - NBA Live, 26 - Dead or Alive, 27 - Lineage, 28 - Virtua Fighter, 29 - Gears of War, 30 - Turok, 31 - Unreal, 32 - Assassin's Creed, 33 - Medal of Honor, 34 - Crash Bandicoot, 35 - Nintendogs, 36 - God of War, 37 - Metal Gear, 38 - Mobile Suit Gundam

COPY AND PASTE THIS WITH EACH NEW VOTE:
Change of rules: From this point on, you may now use two of your negative votes on a single franchise. You still have a total of three negative votes, but they no longer must be spread across three franchises - you can subtract two from one franchise, and one from another. You do not HAVE to, though - you can still spread them out if you want to.

For clarity, and to help others adjust the scores if you happen to sneak one in while they're figuring out their votes, please mark your changes with (+) and (-) and don't forget to remove the old marks.

FINALLY, PLEASE MARK YOUR DOUBLE-SUBTRACTIONS WITH TWO NEGATIVE MARKS: (-)(-) or (--)

I guess everyone ignored my post. I deleted Mobile Suit Gundam.

EDIT: nevermin fixed

EDIT (again): For real. This is it. Everything has been counted and updated. Sorry for messing everyone up (even though it technically wasn't my fault).


14 - Mario (Platformers)


13 - Ace Attorney
13 - Half-Life
13 - Kirby

13 - Legend of Zelda, The
13 - Mega Man
13 - Metroid
13 - Star Fox
13 - Diablo

12 - Dragon Quest
12 - Paper Mario
12 - Pikmin
12 - Ratchet and Clank
12 - Resident Evil

11 - Castlevania
11 - Fire Emblem
11 - Kingdom Hearts
11 - Mario Kart
11 - Super Smash Bros.
11 - Tales

10 - Command and Conquer
10 - Tetris
10 - Bomberman
10 - Donkey Kong
10 - Monster Hunter
10 - Pokemon
10 - Tomb Raider

9 - Age of Empires
9 - Animal Crossing
9 - Banjo Kazooie
9 - Final Fantasy
9 - Guitar Hero
9 - SimCity
9 - Sonic the Hedgehog

8 - Call of Duty
8 - Mario (Sports)
8 - Phantasy Star
8 - Prince of Persia
8 - WarCraft
8 - Mortal Kombat

7 - StarCraft
7 - Doctor Mario
7 - Dynasty Warriors
7 - Jak and Daxter
7 - Star Wars

6 - Brain Age
6 - Devil May Cry
6 - Doom
6 - Fallout
6 - Rayman
6 - Resistance
6 - Rock Band

5 - Lego
5 - Lemmings

4 - James Bond
4 - SOCOM
4 - Soul Calibur
4 - Wii

2 - Tom Clancy
2 - Street Fighter



ELIMINATED 1 - Yu-Gi-Oh!, 2 - Nickelodeon, 3 - WWE SmackDown, 4 - Harry Potter, 5 - Madden NFL, 6 - Grand Theft Auto, 7 - Simple, 8 - Dragonball Z, 9 - FIFA, 10 - Winning Eleven (PES), 11 - Marvel, 12 - Tony Hawk, 13 - Alone in the Dark, 14 - Frogger, 15 - Spyro, 16 - Tekken, 17 - Dance Dance Revolution, 18 - Need for Speed, 19 - Halo, 20 - Mario Party, 21 - The Sims, 22 - Gran Turismo, 23 - Pixar, 24 - Bejeweled, 25 - NBA Live, 26 - Dead or Alive, 27 - Lineage, 28 - Virtua Fighter, 29 - Gears of War, 30 - Turok, 31 - Unreal, 32 - Assassin's Creed, 33 - Medal of Honor, 34 - Crash Bandicoot, 35 - Nintendogs, 36 - God of War, 37 - Metal Gear, 38 - Mobile Suit Gundam

COPY AND PASTE THIS WITH EACH NEW VOTE:
Change of rules: From this point on, you may now use two of your negative votes on a single franchise. You still have a total of three negative votes, but they no longer must be spread across three franchises - you can subtract two from one franchise, and one from another. You do not HAVE to, though - you can still spread them out if you want to.

For clarity, and to help others adjust the scores if you happen to sneak one in while they're figuring out their votes, please mark your changes with (+) and (-) and don't forget to remove the old marks.

FINALLY, PLEASE MARK YOUR DOUBLE-SUBTRACTIONS WITH TWO NEGATIVE MARKS: (-)(-) or (--)

Thanks TopCat.

ummm Zelda was at 15 by the last vote, now its at 13, without any negative votes. that doesnt make sense. should still be at 15, not 13.

14 - Mario (Platformers)


13 - Ace Attorney
13 - Half-Life
13 - Kirby

13 - Legend of Zelda, The
13 - Mega Man
13 - Metroid
13 - Star Fox
13 - Diablo

12 - Dragon Quest
12 - Paper Mario
12 - Pikmin
12 - Ratchet and Clank
12 - Resident Evil

11 - Castlevania
11 - Fire Emblem
11 - Kingdom Hearts
11 - Mario Kart
11 - Super Smash Bros.
11 - Tales

10 - Command and Conquer
10 - Tetris
10 - Bomberman
10 - Donkey Kong
10 - Monster Hunter
10 - Pokemon
10 - Tomb Raider

9 - Age of Empires
9 - Animal Crossing
9 - Banjo Kazooie
9 - Final Fantasy
9 - Guitar Hero
9 - SimCity
9 - Sonic the Hedgehog
9 - Mortal Kombat (+)

8 - Call of Duty
8 - Mario (Sports)
8 - Phantasy Star
8 - Prince of Persia
8 - WarCraft

7 - StarCraft
7 - Doctor Mario
7 - Dynasty Warriors
7 - Jak and Daxter
7 - Star Wars

6 - Brain Age
6 - Devil May Cry
6 - Doom
6 - Fallout
6 - Rayman
6 - Rock Band

5 - Lego
5 - Lemmings

4 - James Bond
4 - SOCOM
4 - Soul Calibur
4 - Wii
4 - Resistance (-) (-)

2 - Tom Clancy

1 - Street Fighter (-)



ELIMINATED 1 - Yu-Gi-Oh!, 2 - Nickelodeon, 3 - WWE SmackDown, 4 - Harry Potter, 5 - Madden NFL, 6 - Grand Theft Auto, 7 - Simple, 8 - Dragonball Z, 9 - FIFA, 10 - Winning Eleven (PES), 11 - Marvel, 12 - Tony Hawk, 13 - Alone in the Dark, 14 - Frogger, 15 - Spyro, 16 - Tekken, 17 - Dance Dance Revolution, 18 - Need for Speed, 19 - Halo, 20 - Mario Party, 21 - The Sims, 22 - Gran Turismo, 23 - Pixar, 24 - Bejeweled, 25 - NBA Live, 26 - Dead or Alive, 27 - Lineage, 28 - Virtua Fighter, 29 - Gears of War, 30 - Turok, 31 - Unreal, 32 - Assassin's Creed, 33 - Medal of Honor, 34 - Crash Bandicoot, 35 - Nintendogs, 36 - God of War, 37 - Metal Gear, 38 - Mobile Suit Gundam

Cactus said: Ahhh. LoZ and FF must not win! I'll make sure this doesn't turn into another GFAQs character battle if it's the last thing I do!

What??  FF is nowhere near the top!

@ bardicverse: Go back a page and you'll see this:

supermario128 said: 14 - Mario (Platformers) (+) 13 - Legend of Zelda, The (--) (Just to put Mario on top for now)

 

 

Seriously seece, you need to start including the rules in your post.

My vote: SF must not die before MK!

14 - Mario (Platformers)

13 - Ace Attorney
13 - Half-Life
13 - Kirby
13 - Legend of Zelda, The
13 - Mega Man
13 - Metroid
13 - Star Fox
13 - Diablo

12 - Dragon Quest
12 - Paper Mario
12 - Pikmin
12 - Ratchet and Clank
12 - Resident Evil

11 - Castlevania
11 - Fire Emblem
11 - Kingdom Hearts
11 - Mario Kart
11 - Super Smash Bros.
11 - Tales

10 - Command and Conquer
10 - Tetris
10 - Bomberman
10 - Donkey Kong
10 - Monster Hunter
10 - Pokemon
10 - Tomb Raider

9 - Age of Empires
9 - Animal Crossing
9 - Banjo Kazooie
9 - Final Fantasy
9 - Guitar Hero
9 - SimCity
9 - Sonic the Hedgehog

8 - Call of Duty
8 - Mario (Sports)
8 - Phantasy Star
8 - Prince of Persia
8 - WarCraft

7 - StarCraft
7 - Doctor Mario
7 - Dynasty Warriors
7 - Jak and Daxter
7 - Mortal Kombat (-) (-)
7 - Star Wars

6 - Brain Age
6 - Devil May Cry
6 - Doom
6 - Fallout
6 - Rayman
6 - Rock Band

5 - Lego
5 - Lemmings

4 - SOCOM
4 - Soul Calibur
4 - Wii
4 - Resistance

3 - James Bond (-)

2 - Tom Clancy
2 - Street Fighter (+)


ELIMINATED 1 - Yu-Gi-Oh!, 2 - Nickelodeon, 3 - WWE SmackDown, 4 - Harry Potter, 5 - Madden NFL, 6 - Grand Theft Auto, 7 - Simple, 8 - Dragonball Z, 9 - FIFA, 10 - Winning Eleven (PES), 11 - Marvel, 12 - Tony Hawk, 13 - Alone in the Dark, 14 - Frogger, 15 - Spyro, 16 - Tekken, 17 - Dance Dance Revolution, 18 - Need for Speed, 19 - Halo, 20 - Mario Party, 21 - The Sims, 22 - Gran Turismo, 23 - Pixar, 24 - Bejeweled, 25 - NBA Live, 26 - Dead or Alive, 27 - Lineage, 28 - Virtua Fighter, 29 - Gears of War, 30 - Turok, 31 - Unreal, 32 - Assassin's Creed, 33 - Medal of Honor, 34 - Crash Bandicoot, 35 - Nintendogs, 36 - God of War, 37 - Metal Gear, 38 - Mobile Suit Gundam

COPY AND PASTE THIS WITH EACH NEW VOTE:
Change of rules: From this point on, you may now use two of your negative votes on a single franchise. You still have a total of three negative votes, but they no longer must be spread across three franchises - you can subtract two from one franchise, and one from another. You do not HAVE to, though - you can still spread them out if you want to.

For clarity, and to help others adjust the scores if you happen to sneak one in while they're figuring out their votes, please mark your changes with (+) and (-) and don't forget to remove the old marks.

FINALLY, PLEASE MARK YOUR DOUBLE-SUBTRACTIONS WITH TWO NEGATIVE MARKS: (-)(-) or (--)