Here is the tally for my thread where you put your top 5 this gen and all time down.

10 points -- 1st

8              -- 2nd

6              -- 3rd

5              -- 4th

4              -- 5th

Top 5 for this gen scores like this: Updated whenever there is added

1. Metal Gear Solid 4                                          =                            153
2. Super Mario Galaxy                                         =                            99
3. Call Of Duty 4                                                 =                            76
4. Gears Of War 2                                               =                            71
5. Legend Of Zelda Twilight Princess                  =                            61
6. Little Big Planet                                              =                            60
7. Super Smash Bros Brawl                                =                             57
8. Mass Effect                                                     =                            43
9. Gears Of War                                                  =                            44
10. Bioshock                                                         =                            42
11. Fable 2                                                            =                            41
12. Uncharted                                                       =                            44
13. Metroid Prime 3                                               =                            33
14. Mario Kart Wii                                                 =                             28
15. Halo 3                                                             =                             26
16. Fallout 3                                                          =                            22
17. Grand Theft Auto 4                                          =                            21
18. Animal Crossing WW                                       =                            18
19. Lost Odyssey                                                   =                             17
20. Resistance Fall Of Man  2                                =                            16
21. Tales Of Vesperia                                            =                            16
22. Disgaea 3                                                       =                             16
23. Elder Scrolls 4 Oblivion                                    =                             15
24. Resident Evil 4 Wii                                           =                             12
25. Portal                                                               =                             11
26. Soul Calibur 4                                                   =                            11
27. Motor Storm                                                    =                            10
28. Burnout Revenge                                            =                            10
29. Zack & Wiki                                                     =                              10
30. Valkyria Chronicles                                         =                              10
31. Tekken DR                                                       =                            10
32. Braid                                                               =                             8
33. Ninja Gaiden 2                                                =                              8
34. Fear                                                                 =                             8
35. Phantom Hourglass                                         =                             8
36. Forza 2                                                            =                             8
37. Jeanne D'Arc                                                    =                             8
38. Elite Beat Agents                                             =                             8  
39. Guitar Hero 3                                                   =                             8
40. Pro Evolution Soccer 2009                               =                             8
41. Ace Attorney DS                                               =                            8
42. Dead Rising                                                      =                             8
43. Dead Space                                                     =                             6
44. Infinite Undiscovery                                         =                             6
45. Enemy Territory Quake Wars                          =                              6
46. Wii Sports                                                       =                              5
47. Resistance Fall Of Man                                    =                              5
48. Viva Piniata                                                      =                             5
49. Fire Emblem RD                                                =                             5
50. Pokemon Pearl                                                =                              5
51. MLB 08 The Show                                            =                              5
52. Ratchet And Clank TOD                                   =                              5
53. Rock Band                                                       =                              4
54. Super Paper Mario                                          =                              4
55. Dokapon Kingdom                                           =                              4
56. Mario Strikers Charged Football                       =                             4
57. MK VS DC                                                         =                             4
58. Final Fantasy IV DS                                          =                             4
59. Bionic Commando Rearmed                             =                              4
60. Heavenly Sword                                               =                             4
61. Enchanted Arms                                               =                             4
62. Devil May Cry 4                                                =                              4
63. Pixel Junk Monsters                                         =                              4

I will keep this updated. So Everyone who hasnt gone into the thread to put in your top 5 games do so.

So far MGS4 is out in front by 54 points. Keep them top 5 coming in.
Top 5 tally will end November 22nd. So anyone that wants to give their top 5 this gen and all time. Go to the thread.

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/thread.php?id=48896&start=50