| Jboy0990 said: I still don't get it, if GoW3 is more difficult than GoW, an GoW is a 2* then how does rating GoW3 a 2* represent its more difficult. Just because a few people say its a 1* don't mean drop it down. That person could be extremely good at the game. I'm pointing out the obvious point. Both GoW1 and 2 could have been platted on EASY...Thats not the case with GoW3. you HAVE to play Titan... Whether some find it difficult or not its still the fact there is that one trophy that distinguishes the difference in the games trophy difficulty. With both GoW1 and 2 you could plat each in 1 playthrough... GoW3 is designed to play twice(1st to know your enemies to help for 2nd Titan playthrough). If people decide to start on Titan thats fine but you will be overwelmed at the first boss fight for at least 10-15 deaths til you memorize their movements. And if we don't use their rating system to help with ours then what do we do. You even said a few posts ago u looked at ps3trophies.org. I'm sorry but statements are flawed and imo the ratings are too. And I've only seen 1 person who said it should be a 1* and it was by a guy who said he got it in about 9 hours which is highly unlikely. With looking for Godly possessions, horns, eyes, and feathers, along with the challenges i don't see it being beaten in 9 hours, mainly cuz the story is around 6 maybe 7 hours long.. But yet u believe his opinion on a 1* rating? hmm? And don't think I'm being rude or an ass I just would like for things to be done fairly and as far as ratings are, i dont see that |
I'll extract the questions from your post and try and answer each:
"if GoW3 is more difficult than GoW, an GoW is a 2* then how does rating GoW3 a 2* represent its more difficult."
- I said that it was slightly more difficulty according to the users of ps3trophies.org by 0.8 (5.8 for GoW3 vs 5.0 GoW). The 5 star scale used here doesn't reflect small diffierences in difficulty like that (and for good reason). If one game has an average of 5.4 and another game has an average of 5.2, technically the game rated 5.4 is more difficult than the game rated 5.2, but they're both going to show up with the same star rating.
"And if we don't use their rating system to help with ours then what do we do. You even said a few posts ago u looked at ps3trophies.org."
- I typically look to ps3trophies as one source when determining a rating, but it isn't the sole source.
"And I've only seen 1 person who said it should be a 1* and it was by a guy who said he got it in about 9 hours which is highly unlikely. With looking for Godly possessions, horns, eyes, and feathers, along with the challenges i don't see it being beaten in 9 hours, mainly cuz the story is around 6 maybe 7 hours long.. But yet u believe his opinion on a 1* rating? hmm?"
- right, only one person suggested it should be a 1*, just like only one person suggested it be a 3* rating. The others (3 or 4 people) said they think it's 2*. Therefore, the average of those suggestions would be 2*. I'm not picking one person's suggestion and going with that, I look at what everyone is saying.
I'm more than willing to hear out suggestions on how we can improve the current rating system and how we can make it more fair. Please post your suggestions if you have some.
