By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - There is no more RRoD people...try to understand.

Stan85 said:
bbsin said:
Stan85 said:
bbsin said:
Stan85 said:
bbsin said:

For every time someone replies on a thread that's trying to convince people that the 360 is RROD free without any direct proof, a 360 somewhere out there gets the RROD.

Tread carefully folks....

 

The proof is in the hardware. The GPU is the source of the rrod,now it doesn`t move from the motherbord,so that`s my proof. Not talking about the hardware or asume something,but disecting the hardware.

And i can`t prove or convince someone that does not want a 360 or hates it.

 

First off, you're just speculating based hardware revisions that the RROD won't ever pop up again. Second, the proof is within reports from retailers and consumer surveys. So no, you do not have any solid proof. Just speculation.

And the GPU was not the only source of the RROD, in fact, it was mainly from the solder. I doubt you know enough about enginnering and electronics to simply say "because they made this smaller, it won't break anymore", so you're not very credible either.

Regarding your last sentence. I own a 360 and do not hate it, but you obviously don't convince me, not unless you give me real proof and an indepth run of the 360's internal hardware and the exact specifics on why RROD happens.

Smaller GPU means less power consumption and LESS heat coming from that chip. Now,with less heat,the motherbord does not bend and the solder is not stressed anymore. The rrod is a long process,when from all that motherboard bending,the solder gives up and rrod appears.

And with the Falcon,a special glue made by ATI (epoxy resin if your care) is applies to the GPU to make sure it DOES NOT stress the solder (this should have been done from the start,but MS wanted to save 50 million $ and from this the RRoD madness). After that,a passive cooler is applyed on the GPU so the heat will be transfered in the area where it will be blown out of the console. With the Jasper model,everything will be cooler.

Any more complaints? Any more hardware details you want to know? Please,don`t be shy.

 

All you did was repeat what I've already read on the first page. Is that all you know? So me the proof where it says the RROD is directly and only caused by a worn solder? do it. If you can, then you got me convinced. Unfortunatly, for you, RROD can be casued by many issues within the 360, even ones that have not existed on previous models.

Like I said, everything you've said is just speculation. I'll PM you, when the first Jasper model RRODs on the internet.

I will make a bet with any of you that the new jasper hardware revision will not be clear of any hardware issues that can render the 360 as unplayable, including the RROD. If you have over 500 posts or is stan85, i'll give up my avatar control and sig control for a year if there are no problems within a year of it's official release and vice versa if there is.

Assuming that the 360 is much more reliable than before is logical and reasonable, claiming that there will be no more problems after a model is released is not.

Fine. I have a friend that fixes them. He applyes the Xclamps on the GPU after heating it and voila,the solder re-touches the motherbord and no more RRoD. I`m not going to lie and say " i fix them myself" , but if you have a question,i will ask his and give you his reply. ANd btw,the bottom memory on the motherbord is not cooled as far as i know,that in a few cases led to rrod. Now with the 60 gb and jasper model,they have dropped that and doubled the capacity of the memory on thetop of the motherbord,where it`s cooled. Good job,MS.

Jasper will probably take your rrod nighmares away,while 2009-2010 Walhalla cip (65 nm cpu,65 nm gpu all in one super chip) will probably make you buy a 360 and stop your hate on MS and it`s products.

And google the 360 rrod cause,i`m not going to bother convincing you about the cause , when i have explained it to you in detail and told you how things work internaly. You seem to know more than i dodon`t you?

Like i said,nothing more i can do.

 

 

Fail. I have friends that can fix 360s aswell (most of the time) but I'm not going to run around trying to get people to buy a 360 based off speculation that there will not be any problems from here on out.

As for my RROD nightmares and my"hate" for MS and it's products....

No, the jasper and "Walhalla cip" won't take them away because:

1. I already had a 360 that RROD once and another that still have disk errors but still functions.

2. Your desperate attempt to clear Microsoft's name as far as hardware manufacturing is concerned, is awful.

3. The "hate" never existed, If you weren't blind, you can see that I play my 360 games all the times and buy their products.

Like I've said before, the solder is not the only cause of the RROD as the RROD stands for "general hardware failure". Before you tell me to google it up, you should google up a microsoft tech or go to their main website and read the description yourself.

I love the fact that since you cannot back up your claims of the future, you label anyone that disagrees with you a "fanboy" or "microsoft hater". Pity, all you've been trying to do all this time is protect your favorite system from "fanboys" but in reality, you've revealed that you are one yourself. This thread = flop.

Bottom line: The jasper will break and RROD still exists, just not as much as previous models. (hopefully)



Around the Network
Staude said:
Stan85 said:
"I support 360 over PS3 but saying RROD is totally gone is BS."

Fair point. You can`t see every Falcon that rrod`s or if any Falcon rrod`s.
However,I don`t see people complaining about the Falcon,which is good. Jasper will be great also.

However,i see people complaining about the ps3 laser and how their games do not run properly,but with glitches. And even the menu has glitches. It`s on youtube and forums,so i don`t lie.
The ps2 had laser problems,sold great.
The ps3 has laser problems,sels great.
The 360 has problems,sels great.

I realy don`t see the problem. However i see the 360 more stable,while the ps3 will continue to have glitches and people calling Sony to get a replacement,wich they always do. Same goes to MS. Everything is peacefull to my eyes.

You are comparing 0.2 percent failure rate with 33 percent. There is.. quite the difference.

 

And for the record. My (close to) launch ps1 still works. So does my ps2. I personally have had no issues with either. That doesn't mean that everyone else didn't either though..

If you don't get my point i'm saying, that even if you don't have the problem.. many other people could.

Oh and there are two l's in sell.

 

Congratulations on your PS1 and PS2 still working.  As you already acknowledge though, this is only anecdotal evidence and not indicative of the bigger picture.  I could talk about my launch 360 that is still going strong or the two PS2s I returned within days of purchasing because they were scratching disks but again, only anecdotal.

I do take exception to the failure rates you quote. Microsoft don't release failure rates, and I imagine Sony don't either (if I'm wrong on that I'm sure someone will correct me).  If you are going to quote figures, please link to your sources.  The reliability issues with the 360 have now been resolved to a degree where the failure rate is 'acceptable', and I imagine it is comparable to the other consoles.  You may still see more RRoD stories but these will predominately be about older 360 consoles.  I see as many PS3 failure stories as 360 revised hardware failure stories on the forums.

 



Holy hell, this thread just blew my mind. Any google search will turn up hundreds of people saying their brand new chip set 360s are still getting RROD. Yet you go with your own type of spin, which I might add is the best type of spin, out right lie.

God bless your soul, my mind being blown might have been the best feeling since my first experience with a woman, if you would like, I'll let you know what thats like.



I own all three current consoles and a great gaming rig, now thats out of the way.

This space Reserved for the Nuggets of Wisdom dropped by Bladeforce:

"Why post something like this when all it will get is PS3 owners blinded to reality replying? BOTH THE PS3 AND BLUE-RAY WILL NOT LAST 3 YEARS! TECHNOLOGY CHANGED TOO FAST!"

"is it Wii FIt that has sold as many as PS3's sold? Thats a LOL Look at the total sales of software is it just me that sees Nintendo titles hitting 10m+ and you say they arent making a difference? Another LOL!"

"Hell, with all the negative hype Sony spin, people just aren't interested cost is too high and to get the true HD experience (1080p, 7.1 surround) you will need a $1000+ system. THAT IS GOING TO DO IT IN A RECESSION! PS4 will not happen"

@ bbsin -> lol.
1. Your disk read error/scratching disks is because of the dvd,buy a samsung or benq off ebay and your done.

2. MS id getting better,i gues now,with the jasper model,the 360 should have sold to the market. But by then,the ps3 will give him no chance,wright? Now you understand the quality testing skipping.
MS should have paid ATI,they didn`t,they failed,life goes on.

3. "Bottom line: The jasper will break and RROD still exists, just not as much as previous models. (hopefully)"
You are the desperate one,not me.
Why do you say that your frinds can fix 360 "most of the time" ? Maybe because they don`t do this for a living? Because they are not proffesionals? Yes. Speculations you say? I fail to see your point. It`s just the truth.

General hardware failure? i have said about the memory,don`t say theoretical stuff... i only said practical things and explinations.

Buttom line? your attempt to discourage people into buying a Jasper are a little weak. The price cut is a plus,360 does well in US.

Anything else i can help you with?



colonelstubbs said:
Stan85 said:
colonelstubbs said:
So there is no more RRoD? So when i hear a report of a case of RRoD its a lie?

Is this what you are saying?

 

 I`m saying that a Falcon will not RRoD,and the new Jasper will...again...not RRoD.

That`s what i`m saying. I also said to get one this Xmass,but you have read what you wanted to.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080830175917AA0geHl

This link may make you cry

Its from yesterday, and the 360 has a falcon chip.

Im sorry

 

 

 Maybe if that link was news and not some dumbass blogger, it would have some precedent.  As is, it's largely meaningless and could be a fluke of just one guy's system--if it's true at all.

 

I don't hear about RROD stories nearly as often any more.  A big chunk of it is just taking better care of your Xbox360.  Many people seem to go the extra mile to create their own problems.



Around the Network

100% of my friends that tried to made get a 360 got rrod at least once.

and at least half after getting a "new" directly from m$, lastest was a month ago.

one managed to get his working so he says by letting it overheat with papel towel



Jo21 said:
100% of my friends that tried to made get a 360 got rrod at least once.

and at least half after getting a "new" directly from m$, lastest was a month ago.

one managed to get his working so he says by letting it overheat with papel towel <<-- no idea if thats true

no i don't think it gone.

 

What is your main language?  I hope to god it is not english.



Jo21 said:
100% of my friends that tried to made get a 360 got rrod at least once.

and at least half after getting a "new" directly from m$, lastest was a month ago.

one managed to get his working so he says by letting it overheat with papel towel <<-- no idea if thats true

no i don't think it gone.

 

 By that you re-connect the solder to the motherboard,but for a short period of time and risk damaging your 360. The Xclamps fix is permanent and doesn`t let the GPU move so the solder does not move,so no more rrod. Very easy,but try to do it professionaly.

And i don`t think the consoles that MS is sending you back are going to last if they don`t have the 2`nd heatsink or are falcons,but that`s my opinion only.

I think this rrod problem is easy to understand.



But what about the RRoD that isn't related to the GPU coming off of the mobo.



SamuelRSmith said:
But what about the RRoD that isn't related to the GPU coming off of the mobo.

 

 The mobo on the 360 is solid,it does not rrod because of that. The GPU is to blame here,then very rarely the bottom memory. Now,that is gone,so really...no more RRoD.

Don`t listen to the rumors,you can`t trust everything. And i have never seen or heard of a mobo failure.