If the only people who offer reviews are the people who like stealthy type games then that doesn't really help out people who may have no experience with the genre now does it?  Just because MGS4 gets a few reviews that are lower than you think they should be doesn't mean that it won't still be one of the best selling and highest quality PS3 games this gen.  Get over it.

This is about as credible as myself putting Mario Galaxy a 7.2 because its the same old mario ,the gameplay is very much the same with the usual changes as in Mario Sunshine ,the graphics arent true next-gen and the story is lame.

The original poster should change his name to XGamer360.That would be appropiate.

Mario games are not meant to be played for their story.  The general gameplay is the same but it is still very fun so that doesn't matter.

The hate is strong in this thread.

The guy finished the game, wrote a well thought out review that explains perfectly how he reached the end score yet all you guys seemingly are able to do is trash the review because it didnt give the score YOU yourselves would have given it.
Or even worse, criticise him without even reading the review.

I've read the review, but XGamer0611, I think you're judging MGS4 on the basis of whether it's Halo 3. It's not meant to be an epic shooter, though you can play it that way.

And what about the storyline? It's one of the most complex, mind-bending narratives ever created. Great female characters, and lots of geopolitical commentary on our war-crazed culture. Don't you see just a few links between Wall Street's financial maniacs and the Patriots' system of total control?