Based on Metacritic Reviews as of June 11, 2007 here are the following breakdowns of cross-platform reviews.
There are 10 games on all three systems (360, PS3, Wii).
Of those 10, the highest scores went to: 6-Xbox360, 2-PS3, 1-Wii and one tie between 360/Wii (Godfather received 77 on both systems)
| Game | 360 | PS3 | Wii | |||
| Tiger Woods PGA Tour 07 | 17-Oct-06 | 80 | 14-Nov-06 | 81 | 13-Mar-07 | 71 |
| Marvel: Ultimate Alliance | 24-Oct-06 | 82 | 17-Nov-06 | 78 | 14-Nov-06 | 73 |
| Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Double Agent | 17-Oct-06 | 85 | 30-Mar-07 | 78 | 27-Nov-06 | 61 |
| Madden NFL 07 | 22-Aug-06 | 80 | 14-Nov-06 | 76 | 14-Nov-06 | 81 |
| Need For Speed Carbon | 31-Oct-06 | 77 | 20-Nov-06 | 74 | 20-Nov-06 | 67 |
| Godfather | 19-Sep-06 | 77 | 20-Mar-07 | 69 | 20-Mar-07 | 77 |
| Blazing Angels: Squadrons of WWII | 23-Mar-06 | 66 | 12-Dec-06 | 67 | 20-Mar-07 | 57 |
| Spider-Man 3 | 4-May-07 | 64 | 4-May-07 | 62 | 4-May-07 | 54 |
| Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End | 22-May-07 | 60 | 22-May-07 | 58 | 22-May-07 | 51 |
| Call of Duty 3 | 7-Nov-06 | 82 | 14-Nov-06 | 80 | 15-Nov-06 | 69 |
Between the 360 and PS3 there are 27 cross-platform games. 21 of those rated higher on the 360 (6 of those by a difference of 5 or more), 4 rated higher on the PS3 and 2 tied.
Between the 360 and the Wii there are 18 cross-platform games. 11 rated higher on the 360 (all 11 by a difference of 5 or more), 3 rated higher on the Wii (one by a difference of 5 or more) and 4 were tied.
Between the PS3 and the Wii there are 10 cross-platform games (same as for all three above). PS3 rated higer for 8 (all 8 by a difference of 5 or more), Wii rated higher for 2 (both by a difference of 5 or more).
Notes: I have included comparisons between Full Auto 1/2, Ridge Racer 6/7, Godfather (different editions), Far Cry (different editions).
