Missed Link going over Samus when I was fixing the list, here's the real values as of now >_

And now for my vote


Link 11 (-2)
Samus 2 (+1)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 2 points from 1 character
3. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman
46. Kerrigan
47. Donkey Kong
48. Luigi
49. Mario

EDIT: See above someone f'ed up the counts

Real count b4 me:

Link 8

Samus 6

Now my vote

Link 6 (-2)
Samus 7 (+1)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 2 points from 1 character
3. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman
46. Kerrigan
47. Donkey Kong
48. Luigi
49. Mario

Superchunk, my most recent one is right (went back and checked three times now just ot make sure )

Should now be Link 9 and Samus 4.

Yes, right for sure this time >_< Have a spreadsheet of votes to prove it :p

Link 9 
Samus 4 
================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 2 points from 1 character
3. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman
46. Kerrigan
47. Donkey Kong
48. Luigi
49. Mario

Votes got mixed up somewhere, I tried to fix them and missed the part where Link went over Samus and messed them up a little more, my last post has them right though.

Went through in a spreadhsheet and recored each vote with the voters name when we went down to two characters. My last list is right but not counting your vote RolStoppable.

Here's a pic of the spreadsheet, somedays I am teh stoopid

Bah, right click, view image, you know the deal. 

Link 8 (+1)
Samus 3 (-2)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 2 points from 1 character
3. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman
46. Kerrigan
47. Donkey Kong
48. Luigi
49. Mario

Link 7 (+1)
Samus 2 (-2)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 2 points from 1 character
3. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman
46. Kerrigan
47. Donkey Kong
48. Luigi
49. Mario

Good to see my screwup is out of the way :p
 

Link 5 (-2)
Samus 3 (+1)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 2 points from 1 character
3. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman
46. Kerrigan
47. Donkey Kong
48. Luigi
49. Mario

Link 6 (+1)
Samus 1 (-2)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 2 points from 1 character
3. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman
46. Kerrigan
47. Donkey Kong
48. Luigi
49. Mario