By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Controversial music vid from Justice, art or encouraging violence???

On may 1st Justice a French electro duo (i love em) released their music vid for their much loved "Stress" which is one of their more hardcore tracks. The video follows a French gang of youths through the subburbs of Paris, mugging, vandelising, assaulting etc. The video is beautifuly directed by Romain Gavras.





heres the link if the embeding hates me as usual


Now I have been having some fierce debates online about this video, I personaly think it is a work of art and the fact that it is evocing so many strong emotions from the viewer just shows how well made it is. Part of what makes it so shocking is just how real it looks which is a hard thing to achieve from a directors point of view, you know this sort of thing goes on but its not normaly right in your face like this.

So what do you think, is it mindless agression and everything thats wrong wih society, or is it a work of art?


Around the Network

not much into techno but I can see your point of this being 'art' art dosent have to be pretty, it can show many emotions, including rage and disgust, and I think this video showed that perfectly.

PS iv been to alot of place this video was shot IE les Sacre Coeur



^^ well put, also the fact that youv been there probably adds to the realism, whereas I had no idea where that was.



Ah the vid gave me great memories of my youth.

Montmare! je ne vais jamais oublier c'est quartier =p.






^^ either you were like one of the people in this gang, you watched a different vid, or you had a fettish for violence as a kid lol!



Around the Network

I don't really like the video but the track is awesome

 



This thread is fairly bumpy



Anything that Aphex Twin & Cunningham did together is better than this (music & video art style). I think even the Basement Jaxx music (and their videos) are better.

But this Justice video is more provocating (and inspired by the movie “La Haine” I suppose), as it puts the finger in the wound of its society and is visually done simple enough to make the right people angry and the right people buy their records and their clothes (the jackets in the video with the band sign can be bought).

Youth culture always takes the simple road to provocate, which is understandable but also a bit boring as the same thing has been done similarily in earlier decades all over the world (starting with the early Rock´n´Roll movies in the 50s).

Director Romain Gavras is Costa´s son, btw. No wonder he´s interested in social & political topics.