I just bought a few hours ago Bullet Wicth in Walmart. I know the reviews are very bad, and I just bought the game because it was on sale at $9.99

 I still have the game unopened... should I play the game or return the game tomorrow?

you decide, play it if u like it keep it, if you don't well back to the hellfires with you.

Bullet Witch is the 360's equivalent of the Wii's Ninjabread man. They are the worst game on the system.

Never played the game but i would a least try it out first

If they are selling Bullet Witch new for $10 it must be really bad.

Bullet Witch. First of all, won't take over 6 hours (most). Second. THough the game seems that had some good potential, they rushed it. The story is pathetic, and the whole scenery ... mmm, lets say uninspired. You'll get bored of killing the same enemies, over and over again, plus there are some bubble enemies that are really annoying. No real feel of the guns, but some noticeable spell that unfortunately have a mandatory 4-5 sec "intro" before casting them. Some of them are impressive though. No multi (and if it had, I wonder you would you play with), absolutely no replayability value, and visuals, that despite the fact that show some interesting elements in the city enviroments, otherwise, they are blund, with a constant fog that doesn't let you enjoy anything. I rent it, played it over a weekend and that's it.
On the other hand 10 dollars are almost 6-7 euros.
I would keep it. Definitely