Jaicee said:
Okay. Lets go through this:
YOUR QUALIFYING STATEMENT: Why offer one? When people offer qualifying statements like, for example, "I'm not a sexist, but..." it's a guaranteed fact that the next phrase will be a sexist one. Why posture as though you care about anyone but yourself when clearly you don't?
Great job mate, judging the guy when you don't know him. You're proving his point.
Now on to your "points".
1. TALENT. I find it remarkable that all women are talentless in your mind by virtue of being female. But I'm not surprised that that's how you view the world.
Where did he say that? Unless you're living under a rock, which you aren't it is apparent that quotas and specific representations are being seeked. Instead of having the market decide what it wants via profit, the dynamics are being changed for false diversity.
2. "BENDING STORYLINES". I wonder if it has ever occurred to you that female human beings, including those of us who are gay, consume media too and sometimes like to actually see stories that we can directly relate too on various levels as well rather than always being expected to view the world through your eyes?
Has it occurred to you that changing a character for the sake of it, is racist, sexist and whatever buzzword sjws use. If you're looking at a character and all you can see is "white", "straight", "male", and you change it for the the purpose of diversity then you're a backwards hypocrite.
I have some unhappy news for you: YOU, as a straight, presumably white, male belong to the most overrepresented demographic in all artistic mediums. Just to casually throw out a couple of factoids that come to mind off the top of my head, two out of every three Hollywood actors are male and you most likely can't even name one female movie director (and if you can, it's Patty Jenkins because of last year's Wonder Woman movie, which you were probably against the production of too). Similarly, in video games...well frankly, just try thinking of a single game you've ever heard of before that was created by a team consisting either mostly or entirely of women. It's not very easy, is it? And what percentage would you say use female-only leads, because I've been gaming for more than 30 years now and I'd say it's consistently been less than 10% of the total that whole time. I could go on down the list of mediums this way -- TV, music, literature, etc. etc. -- but the point is the same: women, and especially those who are gay and/or not white , are dramatically underrepresented and usually presented as stereotypes in as far as they represented at all. You will say that this overrepresentation of men who are white and straight just reflects consumption habits. I will ask you which came first: the proverbial chicken or the egg. You just don't want those traditional consumption patterns to be made at risk of changing is all.
Again great job assuming things about the man, how very mature of you. Also what is wrong with over representation? If these people deserve their jobs, then great. When it comes to video games i shouldn't have to tell you that they simply cater to the audience, and that if you look at games being exposed at E3 close to 50 % of them will have a playable female character.
If you care so much about representation why don't you ask for more males in nursing, for more females in prisons? In mines? in construction sites? I'm sorry to burst your bubble , at large what creates the levels of representation we have today, is talent, personal choice, and the demands of the market.
I point all this out to highlight how selfish and entitled you're being. You use expressions like "diversity" and "bending storylines" to describe representation for anyone belonging to any group but your own. You seem to believe that you are the default sex/race/orientation and that the rest of us are unnatural aberrations undeserving of having our stories told or our fantasies legitimized at all.
Again i have to applaud you for your maturity.
I mean how many games can you actually think of that include gay romance arcs, for example, because very few are coming to my mind. There weren't any that I can even recall around when I was in my teen years, discovering that I was lesbian. Did you know that that level of cultural annihilation can be hurtful and cause one to feel very, very lonely and freakish? But methinks that actually maybe that's how you hope that people like me feel because you don't even think of us as fully human.
If you need to be represented in games and entertainment to feel good about yourself then i'm sorry but you lack a proper education or the presence of a proper support group in your life.
Why aren't you bothered by the far larger number of movies/games/shows/whatever that use all-male casts of lead characters? Why just when it's girls or women?
So you found the way that men are represented in the latest Ghostbusters movie insulting? Congratulations: now you understand how I felt about the way women were represented in the originals! In other words, get over it.
3. STEREOTYPES. I agree with this sentiment technically, but, given the rest of your commentary on the evils of "diversity", can't help but feel that there is a selfish ulterior motive in the back of you mind.
You have no clue what diversity is, diversity is having different opinions, different ideas, different ways of thinking. Not different skin colours, genders, or sexualities. Simply looking at people and classifying them based on gender, race, sexuality is the complete opposite of diversity.
I'm not saying that the world is perfect as it is, and that we don't have some forced representations, but the way of changing that isn't by shoving quotas down the throats of people.
|