Lay down exactly what it is, that to you, screams mafia in your average player. I'm all ears. 

Mine for example I already laid out. Posts with no substance, active lurking, actual lurking, wishy washy opinions, lack of conviction, fear of mislynches, tunneling.

You said, what was it, too much activity, lots of analysis?

Well, continueing on my read on FF (god, I am behind on schedule) some "early" scumspect posting (wooh, exciting, ain't it?)

I guess the one that suprised him was spurge, going for the first 3 mentions: Argueing about Darwin didn't have much merit then - even prof let it go - and yes, no-hurt period is common for new players anyway, not much of a tell. OFC he won't hunt himself and I was garnering suspicion en masse, argueing against that is ludicrous (well, not really that, but there was little reason to do so for him)

Mr.P himself was just the same in terms of public opinion and he showed little motivation to actually argue back at people. Xander was lurking and discussing Baalz is just a small sidenote in current prospect, since we already what baalz flipped and as far as I remember there was no major clash. His argument about historically clashing with him is also what I remember, so ... yeah... meh...

One post to ask Mr.P to fully confirm his "two people for town" claim as bullerproof as there has been some confusion about it. A post about values of participation (town/scum, active/lurker...), I don't get anything from that.

He then proceeds to go after lurking Xander (god did xander choose an aweful post to make for being absent so long, but he went back to not doing anything anyway). He asks if Mr.P can stop playing scummy after Mr.P mentions himself he just feels like playing like scum (omg, I am so wanting to lynch mr.p for all this crap). He then diverts the attention from Mr.P to Xander as he deems Xanders play is intolerable - saying that it doesn't strike me as much unless Mr.P would flip scum, and even then I think that is something a scum FF wouldn't do.

Two topics, one post: First the attempt to gather linkz' townie points, arguing that linkz might have noticed mr.ps appearant awareness towards the 2 noobs one pro scum setup. (also pointing out how Mr.P kinda contradicts himself), second topic being me warm towards Darwin and darwin/me being both mafia. I would like to hear here why he didn't mentioned how likely he deems the inverse. I find the second part of that post kinda lacking in argumentation, as in, how likely he sees it that even one of us is scum, because if he thinks it is a 25% chance that exactly one of us is scum and then gives 70% of that too me it is completely different in meaning than when he thinks it is likely (lets say 80%) that one of us is scum and then says I am 70% likely to be scum in that constellation. It kinda lacks the commitment to a clear statement and it is FFs first thing I fully dislike about his play, because it kinda prevents me from looking into further interaction in this regard. It reminds me of his page 3 post (which I still deem fine in early-ness of the game at that point). It gives me that vibe that he wanted to keep his hands clean on an early (easy) lynch but then when it lost traction wanted to keep it on peoples minds.

((MAJOR EVENT XANDER ANNOUNCES HIM DROPPING OUT))

3 posts about xander dropping out (2 of them more like suggesting a way to fix the problem)

end of page 9@50pp

(I am putting this post here since I accidentally dropped it and am finishing up again - it happened on the end of page 8 just before FF voted xander - and my quick glimpse on it doesn't hold much reason to be discussed)

Overall I found my first thing that does irk me, I am not sure if this is just because it majorly involves me or it struck that much because it is that I am also the only person I can be sure of is town and that is why I was much more aware of him doing what I think his intention was.

I said that, from experience, people that were Mafia usually followed two strategies: either making themselves invisible by lack of activity (trying to blend into the crowd without calling that much attention), and deflecting all the attention by being really active. And you have been very active towards plenty of users.

So by your definition, what gives you the impression that the things I have done don't 'scream mafia'? As far as your knowlege goes, I should be at least a cause for consideration in your eyes. Instead you just rule me out completely and go for Prof. 

exactly my point of asking that question. There have been plenty of users with a lot of activity and "analysis", and there have been a lot that are really quiet.

Darwin's main suspects were me (suddenly starting the suspicion on day 2, despite a passing notice on day 1) for being really active, mrp for unknown reasons- in fact he said this on day 1: "I don't hink M. P is mafia, but if I were him, I wouldn't disclose his role so quickly. I mean, we haven't even taken out someone yet, it's too soon to reveal who is who."

And I think spurge was the other suspect, though I'm not sure why as he didn't follow either of his criteria. As far as lurkers, noc, clyde, and somewhat axum should have caught his attention, and for activity, linkz, ff, and stefl, yet also no mention.

He doesn't follow his own criteria, and also called mrp a suspect despite saying he didn't think mrp was scum just the day before.

The only thing I'm concerned about, is that darwin is just a dumb town and scum are trying to railroad a lynch toward him to discredit other players (myself included)

"Another" implies a second victim, which would be quite alarming for a noob to expect. "Any other" means he would have expected someone to be the victim instead of Baalz. You have a fair point considering he's new to roles and stuff, but if he's town it shows promise for future games.(putting thought into night actions)

Haha, I remember this "bug" now. It even eats most of your post when replying.

This non-content post is brought to you by the letter N.

Quoting for attention. Please answer these:

A Mafia redirector is not just going to out themselves. It's a line of questioning that does nothing to find scum.

1st question: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8168170 Maybe a bit dramatic of me to call that a trap, though :P

 2nd question: About why I think Mr.P is innocent. I don't think his actions or strategies match with Mafia. He was somewhat active at the beginning, until he got a lot of people progressively pointing fingers at him, and them he just pointed himself as a target by voting himself. I think that's the last thing a mafia would do, because of reasons I've explained before (you either blend in, or you convince everyone to accuse another one). If he's doing this, it's in a somewhat desperate attempt to avoid the lynch, but I don't think this trick can work (or even if it does, he won't be able to repeat it twice). And if he's doing this because he's tired of the game, he should just say so or do like Spurge did. A dead outside of the game like that is no fun. That's the reason I asked Mr.P why he's doing this.