By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Mafia Round 74 -Overwatch Theme

theprof00 said:
Basically, if you are town, and someone hammers, and you find something suspicious about clyde that makes you confident he's scum, you basically denied yourself the opportunity to correct your choice.
That seems rather rash thing to do considering you're town trying to lynch only bad guys, don't you think?

Well, I'll unvote until I've finished reading Clyde posts.But if I think Clyde is innocent, I'll vote Mr.P back. Unless he tells us the reason for him to target himself.

Unvote.



You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

Around the Network

Don't worry, I don't expect you to actually have anything to say about clyde. I imagine you just said that to make it seem like you were actually participating and not tring to tran lynch a townie.



Hey, so, what is everyone's opinion on this.
If the vig was able to defeat any one bulletproof role. Let's say there are 2. Which factions bp do you think he'd be able to penetrate?

Ie; sometimes a kill has means of beating bulletproof roles. Like, it is literally taken as bulletproof...bullets only. Nt knives, poison etc.
Lets say the vig has one such kill type that isn't bullets. Who's bp is he more likely to penetrate? Towns bp or scum bp.



theprof00 said:
Ie; sometimes a kill has means of beating bulletproof roles. Like, it is literally taken as bulletproof...bullets only. Nt knives, poison etc.
Lets say the vig has one such kill type that isn't bullets. Who's bp is he more likely to penetrate? Towns bp or scum bp.

What makes you bring up other weapons all of a sudden? So far we have been dealing with 'bullet'proof as a given.



Okay, I've been reading old posts and I've found something interesting. Ironically it's not about Clyde, I have no idea whether he's mafia or not. It's about prof.

So if I read this post correctly:

theprof00 said:
I had a grappling hook. I could take one role and use it immediately.
I do not know if they are told.
It is now gone.
I was told I was attacked.
I saved my own ass.
Now everyone knows I'm helpless.
Now everyone knows my power.
Now I'm pretty much just dead.
Thanks for being so thorough.

I have no idea how I missed this post in the past. He says he's used his hability, and now he can be killed with no real means to defend himself. That means he has publicly targeted himself almost as much as Mr.P did, but for the Mafia. So my theory is this: If nightall comes and goes, and mafia don't kill Prof, I will 99% believe that Prof is a mafia himself. Because, as he himself says, he has no means of defending himself anymore, and it would make little to no sense to let him live (unless they are playing 4th dimensional chess with us, but I can't be always that paranoid).

So he either dies a hero, or lives long enough to see himself become the criminal. Why isn't this a Batman themed mafia? lol

But back to the Clyde topic. I can't read much into him, he tried to lay some traps at the beginning of the second day, and had a discussion with Prof, as lots of people here did. Nothing that screams mafia. So I will keep my vote on Mr. P. for now, until further evidence is discovered.

Vote Mr.P.



You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

Around the Network

When I said get off your asses I meant to be more active, not to end the Day prematurely. I still have questions unanswered and new ones I'd like to ask. Won't be back for a couple of hours though, so do the right thing!

prof, do you want me to answer that when I return?



Darwinianevolution said:

So my theory is this: If nightall comes and goes, and mafia don't kill Prof, I will 99% believe that Prof is a mafia himself.

What if mafia kill someone else specifically to make you think this? I would, if I were them.

In fact, prof is almost guaranteed to live toNight, since he (assuming he is town) is confirmed to have no PR, so no need to bother. Better yet, would be a prime candidate for a mislynch the next Day.



Unvote

With this, Mr.P is no longer one away from being hammered.



miz1q2w3e said:
Unvote

With this, Mr.P is no longer one away from being hammered.

thanks



Linkzmax said:
When I said get off your asses I meant to be more active, not to end the Day prematurely. I still have questions unanswered and new ones I'd like to ask. Won't be back for a couple of hours though, so do the right thing!

prof, do you want me to answer that when I return?

eh, it's really not worth the effort. I thought for a moment that our vig could potentially kill a bp holder cuz he used a hook, but I feel like it's too flavor reliant and wouldn't really give anything concrete.