prof claimed he can steal a power, and stole Mr.P's power, and was BP for that reason.  Not because he is naturally BP.  So both power claims could be true, and still only one (or even zero) town BP. 

Sorry, I meant:  in what previous game did prof vote himself? 

Between darwin and clyde, who would you rather see lynched and why? 

It was last game where I claimed town doc, and zero and spurge kept thinking I was scum, so I said fine, kill me, and voted myself.

As for your second question, I dunno. I think both are scum. I could go either way.

If I were to contemplate which of their potential roles are better as scum, I'd probably say Clyde's is more important to the scum team.

Gonna do this in small bits, but the first thing about FF is that I can better understand why I came thinking into day 2 he is town (I still think he is, but I want to see if it is valid. It was his quite sober approach displayed in his post about my reaction to prof and how it could be like a charade and stuff. He also didn't jump too hard into the third party speculations, which I also deem good. Overall his attitude towards my whole lynchtrain seemed pretty chill... maybe too chill... I think he was also the one of the people that sparked discussion at that point that went beyond my lynch and weather or not third party is a thing, granted though, the spark he granted with lynching lurkers isn't really something as clean, I am not sure if one of the initial posts in that regard had a time-context I am missing on this first fly-over.

Noctis reads FFs actions as fishy at this point, mostly revolving about interactions with linkz here (grabed the quote three for densities sake). He never gets to do his experiment cuz Mr.P instaclaims (btw, curious about this one if you still remember, what was it going to be?) - (nevermind there it was in his next post) I think that was a point were we pretty much stalled because of us waiting for Mr.P to do something. He drops from the Mr.P lynchtrain because of baalz vote for mr.p.

@Linkz

Gonna look it up now - out of my mind i only remember the post where you actually pointed out that what he claimed makes no sense (something by the lines of mafia not killing mr.p makes mr.p look scummy to him when he thought mr.p was town, and from what I remember he only did it after it was pointed out that his leeway period is over).

Reminder to myself page7@50pp

I can kinda see myself tracing my thought process, but I am not able to gather much new - the only thing new on my mind is actually that discussion with noctis when thinking about final-fan.

I don't think anything he did is too scummy, but I can follow noctis' thought of FF being scummy than miz' thought of noctis being scummy at this point.

Talking about it, with noctis I have the next person my read is probably too weak on.

Okay I have to admit I harshly misremembered that post of his, I kinda had it on my mind it spiraled into mr.p being scum for sure and prof maybe being his mate. The rest of the discussion about mr.p basically stemed from this post and was perceived by me as him still riding that topic.

I think noctis is a potential scum.
My major points I look for is wishy washy contributions, saying things like maybe/maybe not, hanging back, voting after the train starts, just kind of being here without saying too much.
I think both my leads and noctis fit this description.

Well, just for starters, town busdriver is actually a very swingy role, and can cause major confusion. I would suggest maybe looking up roles on your own so you can form your own opinions. But I'll just leave this page and excerpt here:
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Bus_Driver
"Bus Driver has been seen as each alignment and historically is a pro-Town role; however, some moderators consider Bus Driver to be a Negative Utility role in Town hands, since it is more likely to thwart or confuse power roles than help. The pro-Town intent of this role is to attempt to redirect the scum's kill onto a better target."

"As a pro-Town power role, Bus Driver is similar to a Doctor in that it can prevent a player from being killed if the Bus Driver targets them each Night. However, it does not stop the kill on its own, so it is not as much of a disadvantage to scum if used in this way. With that said, it is far more likely that the Bus Driver will hurt the other power roles as their actions get unexpectedly redirected by the Bus Driver's choices. Thus, it is not considered a great power role."

There is a note about busdriver and bp having a wombocombo to make the busdriver a doctor, but I don't think anyone thinks the bp automatically makes mrp town. I think 90% of the players here think he's a mafia BP.