ok I just read his day 1 from last game, he got really defensive when I called him out.
Last game he also voted for xander because xander was absent. Except last game he said, xander is so distant, he's not even a threat.
But then he put a vote on him later, something I called out. He was very overly defensive and undermining.
Does he fit that description this game?

Can someone with unbiased eyes tell me yes or no, because I don't see it.

Well in this game he didn't really start out defensive, it was only later(if memory serves me correct, doing a re-read now) that he really got defensive.

From what I've gathered from the previous games, mrP is generally an antsy player, but especially so as mafia. When accused, he explodes, underming everything and everyone involved. It's how I caught him day 1 last game. He gets incredibly defensive.
I just don't see it.

Normally he goes right after his accuser, he didn't at all with linkz.

That doesn't describe him this game, I'm afraid.

Afraid, because it looks like we're lynching him.

The one thing I'm betting on is something I noticed, which depends on me trusting linkz. Do you trust him this game, prof?

Indeed. From the looks of it it wasn't until he got fed up with everything that he started getting really defensive.

unvote

I'm not sure if I want to risk it. We have 5 minutes. @miz, if you want to present anything, do it now.

The defensiveness isn't the same.
Here he says things like, "if linkz had just read X then this wouldnt have happened"
or
"what the flip are you smoking" to baalz.

In his mafia games, he was more like,
"that's exactly what you want the town to think, so your mafia buddies can do X"
or
"you're intentionally making things up, you are suspect because of this, and you're accusing me when you won't even defend your suspicious behavior. You are scum"

I have nothing more than what I already mentioned. My argument depends on trusting linkz.

It's tied, at the moment. 1 minute left. Night night, everyone.

I think this is the right decision. I will take the blame if he is scum.
Sorry linkz, I just can't rightfully say this matches his scum play.

Whoever is alive tomorrow, look at darwin and stefl plz. thanks.