As for right here, right now: I take it you don't buy Mr.P's PR claim? I do, so I wanna hear why you don't.

I don't believe he is town, whether or not he is in fact BP. See roughly half of my posts since I voted Mr.P if you're curious why.

Why was it instilled in me my first maybe dozen games that giving away a role is bad business, but all of a sudden the last few games people are pushing for it day one, day two, etc.

Lets say everyone is telling the truth about having a role who has come forward or hinted so far. You are just putting a target on your head for scum. Sure you are also helping possible get us on yourside and giving the doc and other roles targets as well. But not only does it put a target on you, it gives people a chance to plan against you and set up scenarios where your lying.

I also agree that it is nice to give us a heads up so we feel better about someone, and that is done by hints. You either catch those hints or you do not.

If you guys see these hints how about you just not draw attention to it. We have 3-4 people who have outed their roles now. 

@drunkmax

You actually have to have big balls to just blindly go into night one with possibly taking three town players out. When you post that I assume you said it because of my last post. So you obviously did not drink yourself blind when you saw it.

Now I am going to get flak for this, I kind of have a Prof, Darwin, Mr.P vibe.

Prof does not have Darwin on his vote list yet has talked about him for half the game. Basically leading him along the whole game. Your buddying, your possibly posting from dead threads, etc. Yet he has such strong convictions on him that he ...does nothing.

Then we have Mr. P, First he has a highly imaginative role, then prof basically goes right along with it and only goes onto "Get townie points" and say a few points about him. Mr. P is quick to jump on the prof train as well just because he agrees with him.

So that is what day one does for you linkz. Everyone all over the place. Look at the votals, we have half on a no lynch, half on a Mr. P and others just all over the place.

Why was it instilled in me my first maybe dozen games that giving away a role is bad business, but all of a sudden the last few games people are pushing for it day one, day two, etc.

Lets say everyone is telling the truth about having a role who has come forward or hinted so far. You are just putting a target on your head for scum. Sure you are also helping possible get us on yourside and giving the doc and other roles targets as well. But not only does it put a target on you, it gives people a chance to plan against you and set up scenarios where your lying.

I also agree that it is nice to give us a heads up so we feel better about someone, and that is done by hints. You either catch those hints or you do not.

If you guys see these hints how about you just not draw attention to it. We have 3-4 people who have outed their roles now. 

@drunkmax

You actually have to have big balls to just blindly go into night one with possibly taking three town players out. When you post that I assume you said it because of my last post. So you obviously did not drink yourself blind when you saw it.

Now I am going to get flak for this, I kind of have a Prof, Darwin, Mr.P vibe.

Prof does not have Darwin on his vote list yet has talked about him for half the game. Basically leading him along the whole game. Your buddying, your possibly posting from dead threads, etc. Yet he has such strong convictions on him that he ...does nothing.

Then we have Mr. P, First he has a highly imaginative role, then prof basically goes right along with it and only goes onto "Get townie points" and say a few points about him. Mr. P is quick to jump on the prof train as well just because he agrees with him.

So that is what day one does for you linkz. Everyone all over the place. Look at the votals, we have half on a no lynch, half on a Mr. P and others just all over the place.