That's hilarious :P

I don't necessarily rule out his bulletproof claim, only that he is a townie.
There could easily be a bulletproof 3rd party. If he truly thinks this takes scums view off of him at night, it would certainly be a logical move (in his opinion) to reveal nice and early like he did.
I also have not ruled out a bulletproof mafia, although this would need to be coupled with a serial killer for the role to even make sense.

I think Mr. P is saying all the wrong things. Though whether or not he's scum or just doesn't know any better remains to be seen. There are some cases where if a mafia were running his mouth and making himself look suspicious, the other mafias would tell him to stop in their chat. Though I've been burned by this assumption in the past. 

Also the post I made about stefl was in response to one of these posts that you made earlier. People were on a wagon that Stefl was third party, and I just said that a third party would be a safe lynch.

So.....suspects?

I'd give a HoS to Mr. P just by the way he handled being put under pressure, and a FoS to Baal.

Baal was a vibe I got a bit back, I'd have to look through the posts to find out where it was.

Sorry about awful formatting in my last how many posts. Here's to voting for the chartz getting a mobile app.

Question to Baalz
You said, "There could easily be a bulletproof 3rd party. If he truly thinks this takes scums view off of him at night, it would certainly be a logical move (in his opinion) to reveal nice and early like he did."

But then, a BP townie would be able to use the same logical reveal, correct? So, we're just looking at scenarios wherein he is definitely a BP, but not a town, right?

And I agree that a mafia BP would strongly suggest an SK.

So in both scenarios, shouldn't we be strongly certain there is an SK, as SK is usually BP once, and Mafia BP would likely confirm SK?

Well yea, I've gotten a scum vibe from him, so I'm essentially trying to lay out the possible scenarios in which he is BP, but isn't a townie (There is still always the chance the BP was completely made up, but that is an even riskier move on his part imo).

As for both scenarios, I don't think a 3rd party BP necessarily implies anything about a SK as well. It could just be to give him a bit more of a chance.

Haven't read through everything yet, didn't expect that much of an explosion of posts - anyway, as prof asked me: I don't think much on darwin yet, his posts are mainly useless or roleplaying so far, he also seemed to lack direction and maybe he took my opinion because I was the first? one to talk to him about other things than the roleplay directly? Beyond that I don't have many thoughts on him.

I wasn't too bothered by FF so far, he could just as well be scum as he could be town, but right now I am leaning town. His weird post about his brain saying I am town and his guts don't trust me, is the weirdest thing to me. There wasn't that much there yet to make him swing his opinion that easily.

@baalz
What third party would have BP?